Heroic Love
	
	Edward Loomis
	IN A SMALL TOWN, a hero is a civic responsibility, for everyone to participate in, for everyone to enjoy. A hero receives attention because he belongs to the people in whose esteem his heroism lives, and this means that a hero has a hard life; this means that a hero will often be troubled by friendly people, and this will introduce the career of Orville Ledyard, once the hero of our town and now one of our most distinguished citizens.
  he name of our town is Albo, and it is the county seat of a big county in eastern California; an old town for a western town, in a desert valley first seen by Americans when the great scout Jedediah Smith passed through on his way to the Humboldt River. There are two kinds of ruins. The first kind is abandoned ranches; the water which once kept them green now flows in an aqueduct to Los Angeles. It is cold water, which flows down from the Sierra Nevada range; in season, we are allowed to take fish from it before it reaches the reservoirs to the south. The other kind of ruins is invisible now; our big cottonwoods have roots which here and there coil among the ruins of the Albo Fort, which was built here by John C. Fremont more than a hundred years ago. The adobe has crumbled away, the pine logs have rotted.
  ut when Orville Ledyard was a hero, there were many ranches, and many cattle climbing to the mountains during the summer, and Albo was smaller than it is now by some thousand-odd souls. That was before the Great Depression, when Albo was a little back-country cattle and mining town of some fifteen hundred people; when the road to Los Angeles was still washboard gravel; when most of the travel through town moved on the narrow-gauge railroad that ran from Reno to Los Angeles; when I was younger, and less charitable, and more ready for adventure; when I was practicing law in two rooms above Jacob Alexander's Barber Shop; and when, in spite of twelve churches (not counting the Roman Catholic church for Mexicans and renegade Piutes), I had managed to get and hold a mistress, the young wife of a competitor-altogether, a time which seems long ago, the halcyon days of youth.
  lbo then was not too far removed from the frontier, in time or in spirit, and its virtues were therefore frontier virtues, its heroes necessarily of the type who are happy in wild places. A hero in such a place at such a time would have to be a man of action, that is my point; and so Orville Ledyard was a man of action.
  ut of a rare type! True, he performed one remarkable act of disinterested physical heroism; it was written up in our paper, and even won a mention in the Carson City paper; I will tell you about it. And, beyond that, he was the kind of man who could be expected to perform such exploits; among other things, he was a cowboy. In that long-ago time when I first knew Orville Ledyard, there were cowboys in the valley, and of these cowboys Orville, then just twenty-one years of age, was acknowledged the best. He had been born an only child on a cattle ranch in Nevada, just over the line toward Gold Point, and raised there until he was twelve years old, when his father had bought another ranch just north of Albo; and there Orville was living alone when I first knew him, his mother and father having died of influenza when he was sixtccn.
  ingle-handedly Orville had managed the ranch, and kept a good white-faced herd when that was not often done in that country. He was a California cowboy, a dally-roper whose saddle had to have a huge horn. He rode a center-fire saddle and occasionally used the spade bit, thus accepting without question the customs of his own country. But he was a good roper and a beautiful rider, who had started at the age of fifteen winning every roping event and both bucking-horse events in the September rodeos at Albo.
  nd he was a hunter. He knew the slopes and high valleys where deer wandered in the Sierra, and he knew the distant meadows of the Piute Mountains, where in stately arrogance and ease the bucks grew to such great age that sometimes the horns fell from their narrow skulls. Each year he trapped mustangs on the high plains of Nevada.
   good cowboy, a tough young man. Small wonder that when he acted bravely one cool night he became an accepted hero, the people of the town had been waiting for him to act so, to fix his image for us as the supple Achilles of our dust and sorrows. It was Orville, a boy of twenty-one, who crept into the darkness of the back rooms of Mason's Hardware Store in search of a Chinese cook of indeterminate age who had shot three people with a stolen revolver and thrown a meat cleaver at a Negro dishwasher. Orville acted while older mcn stood by wondering.
  e were a small town then, so that I could not miss hearing the shooting. It was ten o'clock of a cool April night when I arrived in front of Mason's store, where a crowd of men and boys had gathered; and it was from this group, this twitching multitude, that Orville was detaching himself as I arrived. It was the right crowd for the occasion, a mean crowd, a trifling crowd, but with just enough good men in it to make Orville's isolation an honor to him. A homely legend was gathering itself in that windy street, an ominous but somehow handsome little scene deficient in light, like those darkness-filled photographs of the Civil War which have made Brady famous. I could sense that a thing was about to happen which would be remembered for a long time in our town.
  Old China boy's in the back rooms of Mason's!" someone shouted to me. "Already shot three and cleavered one!"
  rville stood clear of the others. He was wearing a heavy black serge suit, his only one, reserved for church and for his weekly visits to town, and a light tan Stetson of huge brim, so that as he stood there in the dusty road, in the uncertain light, he made a fine and striking figure. He stood with hands on hips, unmoving, as lights pattered across him.
  Where's the marshal?" I asked one of the men in the crowd, and was told that the marshal had gone to Tonopah after a Piute who had escaped from our jail. I knew that the county sheriff was not in town, and thus I knew that there was no authority for Orville to found his action on, and none of the moral support that sometimes comes with responsibility.
  e was deliberate, but quick. He removed his coat, folded it, and set it on the ground at his feet; then he pulled his boots off and set them beside the coat; and then he started walking toward the front of Mason's store as the crowd grew quiet. In a ragged, gasping silence he paused at the door long enough to unlock it; long enough for me to hear several people say that he would be all right until he started into the back rooms; and then he disappeared into the darkness that taped behind the open door. He closed the door behind him. I knew that he wanted no light behind him as he moved in, and this was technical knowledge which comforted me; but I knew also that I was seeing something seen by other men in other lands before me-the gritty little fact that makes a core for legends. Now, remembering, I think of Ulysses with his charred stake poised above the huge, animal-like eye; of Beowulf wimming downward into the mere.
  ext came silence, which lasted a long time; long enough for me to achieve a feeling of guilt for my idleness; long enough for a few others in the crowd to do the same, and show it by scuffing their boots unhappily, like saddened boys, in the dust of the street. Now and then someone whispered; but the crowd would have no noise. Fierce angry stares impaled the whisperers, and I began to sense a devotional quality in the assembly, the kind of emotional heat that comes with worship.
  hus, noise from within the hardware store caused the release of intricate pressures in the crowd. There was a thick and wavering sigh. The noise from the crowd stopped-it had been mere noise, a racket-and the crowd moved forward a little until the leaders, aware of what might happen, shamefacedly stopped. I felt unhappy then, and I could sense t hat others felt so.
  nd then Orville appeared at the door he had entered, half carrying, half dragging the small figure of a man-the ChinaMan, his queue disordered. Instantly the crowd raced forward, and someone shouted something at the Chinaman; someone else called, clearly: "Lynch the Chink son-of-abitch!"
  nly two or three such cries, as I remember; not more, because most of the men in the crowd were waiting to take instruction from Orville; but those cries of rage completed the occasion. They represented human wickedness there in the dusty street, in the cool air, and thus they provided Orville with something to bear against. He represented human goodness in the midst of action-what is called heroism, in fact; and now the cries of rage gave his quality a chance to be seen.
  e raised his left hand; his right was holding the Chinaman by the shoulder. He held his left hand steady and spoke sharply.
  Stand back!" he said. "Stand back!"
  lowly the crowd caught its movement in its own entanglements. The leaders stopped, and then the crowd stopped.
  That's better," Orville said. "Now, listen here. I'm going to tell it just the once. This man is going to get his trial! Anyone bothers this man before he has his trial will have to reckon with me. Right now, here, I stand for law and order, gentlemen! "
  hat was the end of the scene. Orville regained his coat and boots, which were brought to him by admiring boys, and then took the Chinaman to the town jail and stayed there with him until the crowd broke up. Altogether, a good job of work for a young man, and certainly enough to make a hero out of him, at least in our town. People met on the streets and told one another the story, agreeing that it was a lucky thing for the town's future to have Orville in it. When, after the trial some three months later, the Chinaman was taken away to be executed, Orville's deed was gratefully remembered, and it was agreed that his young presence refined the town's moral tone.
  o much for rude action. Now it is my duty to claim that
Orville was a man of mind; a true statement, it is, and I will
stand by it. He was fortunate in his education, which was
good for him in a way that few educations can be good these
clays, for it helped make him a better man. His father, a Missourian, taught him Latin and a love of reading, and his
mother encouraged him. He studied hard at his schools and
performed well, but the private lessons in his home and much
reading had the greatest effect in forming his mind. By the
time he was sixteen, he told me once, he had already read
Gibbon, Macaulay, and Hume. These works must have
helped him learn that gravity of manner which later won
him such favor with the town's ladies. He read Shakespeare, of course, and of fiction he read the standard authors of the nineteenth century, Dickens, Scott, Thackeray, and a few of the humorists. Long afterward he could still laugh at Surtees. And naturally he read widely in the normal Latin authors. He could chant Virgil indefinitely, and knew Persius; he quoted Tacitus, whom he admired as the strongest writer of the Silver Age, and once he recited for me the closing passage of the Agricola, causing himself to be near tears at the end.
   rare type, as I have said. But neither his skill as a cowboy nor his learning would have astounded me if he had not so harmoniously possessed them. He was no double man; his was a single nature, an honest progression of acts accomplishcd with the precision due them. His work gave him hard kinds, with calluses polished into the palms by the hard lariat ropes he used. His work kept him outside during the day, darkening his face and hardening his body, so that in appearance, during the day, he looked the medium-sized young cowboy that he was; just as by night, when he sat bent heavily upon books, he looked the young student in the first daze of learning. But he was something more than cowboy or student or any mere succession of these restricting states: he was that rarity, a lucky man, born to health and vigor, born with the gifts of mind, and trained young to respect his sense of what was right; which was a good, reasonably strong sense, about as sturdy as a young man has a right to expect.
  s he told me once, after the incident of the Chinaman, "When a man knows he should do something, then it's worth his soul not to do it, and that's all there is to it. And so I try to do the things I know I should do."
  nd his respect for the right, in part an inheritance from his parents, in part a victory won from his studies, gave a most pleasing outline to his capabilities. He had a country face, one of those Texas or Arizona faces, ruddy and cleanlined, with chapped lips and sunburnt cheekbones, so that it took some imagination to comprehend his quality, but I was able to do it. It was natural that I should recognize his quality as soon as I discovered his range. Well I remember my surprise at finding a cowboy who read Tacitus-at finding such a man in such a dusty, sweaty, cattle-stinking place.
And I remember well that in Orville Ledyard as he was when I first knew him, I recognized a genuine, if limited, possibility of American greatness. A homely figure, he was; a rustic, even antic gait, and a rough conversation, but as fine a prospect as any I ever met with. Americans are optimists; I'm American, and so why not believe that Orville's gifts would prosper? He caused me to think of our great men; not of the New Englanders, of course, but of the Virginians and Kentuckians, of the wry long-headed men from Ohio and Illinois, doughty men of fine spirit; and of other great men, for Orville's grace was not provincial.
  e had such fine brown eyes, our Orville of the heroic period! Ingenuous eyes, but radiant with guile; he meant no harm, he even meant well, but he comprehended most of our failings; he confronted his world, that motley world-of descrt, mountains, cattle, and a dusty town, and of the sonorities of Silver Age Latin flooding his mind in the cold desert nights-with the clear intention of taking what he needed, what was best for him to take. It was, then, a measure of his innocence, of his honesty, that he was also prepared to heed his sense of what was right; drawn tense between intelligence and innocence he had his being in those happy days.
  t was no surprise that he should have decided, some time before I knew him, to take up the law, for that was the profcssion above all others available to him which seemed to offer a ground for heroic achievement. So it has been, in America; and certainly I sometimes regarded Orville as a boy who might become president. Even at twenty-one he had a good share of the lofty port and presence needed for the task. Like Tom Sawyer in that melancholy epigram, he was a boy who could go far if he escaped hanging. Of course Orville was already past the college age as he made his preparations. He was saving money earned by the ranch, and that was a slow and difficult process, but he was not at all fainthearted, and he had encouragement from my worthy competitor in Albo and my senior, Cassius Martin.
  hat was a man named for the Last of the Romans, and well named, for he was a severe, high-scrupled man, and Caissius could well meet Orville and instruct him, for Cassius controlled an elegant Latinity and a fine speaking voice. He was an impressive man, and kind in his way, respected and well liked in our town.
  ut the fact that Orville came to the law, came late, and through the kindness of Cassius Martin, through advice which confirmed a generalized paternalism, a fact which was in no real sense an accident, did finally involve the accidental, and in a most banal fashion: through the wife of Cassius, a handsome girl named Rose, some twenty years younger than Cassius. She was a decent girl, I believe. I respect her even now, and at that long-ago time I sometimes thought I loved her, and was intermittently sure of it during the more than two years when she served as my mistress.
  or she was indeed my mistress. With her I had dishonored most of the dark corners of Cassius's house, and his bed as well; been happy in nighttime rambles, and gone singing home on many cold dark mornings. A warm-natured girl she was, ever froward, ever constant in her favors to me; and so the unhappy accident which she meant for Orville Ledyard was truly startling, and remains so in memory. I had a privileged position, as you can see. I had access to Orville as well as to Cassius, and I knew Rose. I could view that little cluster of human beings, the middle-aged man, the young wife, and the young man, as none of them could view the others, for no one was watching me. I was there, at the heart of the tempest, like that vacuum, that emptied air, which is the center of a hurricane. And of course what I saw was that Orville had fallen in love with Rose and desired her, and that Rose, my own Rose whom I sometimes loved, responded as any woman might respond to a man like Orville; and I did not miss the great fact in this tempest, which was that Orville could not bring himself to betray his benefactor.
  hat other decision could such a man make? Better for him perhaps, as things turned out, and better for most heroes in the same unhappy fix, if he had made some coarse assault and argued with his conscience later. Suppose he had taken her from me and held her awhile; could Cassius have been the poorer? But then Orville did not know that he would have to take poor Rose from me, and so he felt anguish whenever Cassius spoke to him kindly, and almost visibly quivered sometimes when Rose was near.
  he situation had developed quite naturally from Orville's great deed accomplished upon the Chinaman. At that time he was reading with Cassius in Latin literature and in the law, as a preparation for his entry into college, which was scheduled for sometime a year or so later. As it happened, he had been coming from one of his sessions with Cassius on the night the Chinaman ran wild. At the same time, or epoch, in our lives, Rose had already been my mistress for almost a year and a half, and we were both reasonably happy, though hardly very calm, in our arrangements. We were the kind of lovers who speak rather more often of making love than of being in it. We came together with a friendly but never gentlc hcat.
  s to the secret of our arrangement, I would say that it was the normal secret of such arrangements. Rose was tired of her husband, Cassius; tired of his absorption in his work, in his Latin, in his wide and cheerful reading; and unhappy without knowing the reason for it because she had no child. A new man could please her merely by being new. I, of course, was struggling along young and unattached, with normal instincts and only-normal powers of control. In those days any opportunity could be my undoing, and Rose was a pretty girl who was willing to be an opportunity. Thus we werre quite normal about our perfidy; we were dark with it in the places where anybody would in time be dark, stained in the will and sensibility.
  inally, to complete this image, I believe that Orville by this time already admired Rose. There was no compelling reason why he should not. She was a good-looking darkhaircd woman--not the prettiest in town, and certainly no rarity even there, but satisfactory. She was, in appearance, rather equally suited to a church choir in a small town and to city hotels, and this says omething about her. She had the kind of authority that enables a woman to be at ease with waiters, and to show anger without losing poise; the kind of authority that often goes with a trimmed and careful hardness of character; and so she was a little hard, in her intelligent way. She was a town girl who had once been a country girl and who could become a city girl with ease. Handsome but firm, that was her type. Her special attraction of face was a delicacy of bone at cheek and temple, so that her skin was marvelously smooth at those places.
  n figure she had another kind of authority. She had a full but somehow disciplined and athletic body, and that body in its movements could have a sinewy elegance-but only when she wished it to, when she had a cause to press. She could do what she liked with that little rump, that rising breast.
  nd Rose had, I must confess, a faintly wanton look. A man staring at her might well believe she promised potent delights. It was only a matter, for me, of completing a circle of emotional logic to guess the impression she must have made on Orville when later, in addition to showing herself to him, she allowed him to understand that she loved him, that he could have for himself those charms which so dismayed him. How his heart must have thumped for her then--and his neck reddened! It saddens me to think about his sufferings afterward.
  hus, being smitten early, perhaps at the instance of a light fit of flirting on the part of Rose, but not showing it, Orville was especially vulnerable when Rose began a determined attack. This is a guess, of course, but, if true, it would explain the suddenness of the kindling when finally that kindling happened; a kindling which came, I know, largely by Rose's choosing and, most unhappily, by my original folly.
  or it was I, of course, who told Rose about Orville's act of eroism. Some two or three nights after it, Cassius being out of town on an errand to Carson City, I arrived at the back door of the Martin house and was admitted warmly, by Rose, to the house and to the favors I had come seeking. Latcr, while we lay quietly in the big fourposter bed upstairs, it seemed amusing to tell Rose about Orville's bravery.
  t was a big frame house, painted white, with tall narrow windows, steep roofs, and scrollwork at the eaves; a fact about the house was that it could have that absurd scrollwork and still retain its look of right-angled severity. There was a porch on the east face of the house, and on the porch a small glass-topped table, a swing, and two rocking chairs--a Middle Western house, it was, of the kind you can still see in places like Topeka and Des Moines; on summer evenings there will be a man in shirt sleeves in the front yard, watering thc lawn.
  n such a house I felt like a stranger, a far-wanderer. It was a good sober house, with a dozen rooms in it, but the rooms had gone hollow on that husbandless night. Any little sound could have a booming echo in that emptiness; small sounds grew big a little while after they happened. There was a wind, and it did things to shutters, and to the big cottonwoods outside, which were just coming green again; and there was about half a moon, which gave us a silver light for our pleasures, and gave to Rose's face, where it lay on the pillow, a glaze of light which almost made her look pure. I remember watching her face in that somber chilly light as I talked, and thinking that the face must be cold because of the coldncss of the light; and so I reached out and touched her check and temple, and found the skin oily and hot to my touch, as if with lust, or love.
  ut I talked on, until I was ready to touch her again, this time for my pleasure, and gave her a full accounting of Orville's new-won greatness; but when I touched her, she turned away, claiming fatigue. When I tried again later, she claimed sleepiness, saying in a dim voice that she had been unable to rest the night before and the night before that. Thus she delivered an intimation of a meaning, and the meaning was not lost on me. She did not do it again for a long time, but I understood then, and more clearly later, what had happened.
  hat night I lost her, such was the fact, though the event of loss did not for some time show itself. As Walter Scott might have said, I lost her heart--her poor dislocated heart, so swelling with love. Some part of her stained soul I kept, and have with me still, in honorable memory of our lechery, but her I lost, the woman to give pleasure and comfort I lost that night, through my own folly, to the image of a young man which I had so corrected for her yearnings that she could not resist it.
  ltogether, I see now, it makes a bill of some size and consequence against Rose; and yet she was not quite that kind of girl. I had given her eyes with which to see Orville, whom before she had never really noticed because he was only a cowboy who came sometimes to take up Cassius's time with his desire for education; and so she saw him, and confirmed the image I had given her. Favor her with credit, I say. She was impressed by a man; she did not love an emptiness.
  ow Cassius ever missed her new inclination I could not then understand. True, she did not send me away or lock her doors against me--chiefly, I believe, because she feared retaliation--and her commitment to me may have kept her spirits and behavior filled out to a properly decent outline; but to my eye she seemed openly in love with Orville, and unable to avoid showing it when he was near.
   remember one night a week or so after my telling Orville's story to Rose. I had gone to the Martin house to find Rose and arrange a meeting for later in the week; ostensibly I had come for conversation with Cassius about law and politics. I found Orville there, in the room which Cassius had taught Rose to call the parlor, with Rose and Cassius both present. Cassius and Orville each had a book--a Latin text, I forget the author--and it was clear that this was not a regular thing. Cassius was a little put out, ill at ease. Orville was red in the face, and somehow both uncomfortable and intensely happy.
  t was one of those arrangements of people which a newcomer can sometimes read like a newspaper headline.
  Rose thinks she can learn Latin by listening to us," Cassius said harshly. "You see she's here. And yet I can no more get her interested in the Latin grammar ..." Cassius let his sentence go and shook his head.
  I think hearing the Latin may give me an interest," Rose said. "It's a new idea of mine. I like to hear men's voices."
  rville said nothing at all, but I knew that he understood very well what Rose had come seeking. And so I was in no position to stay long; it was apparent that Rose would not be ready to make arrangements for meeting me. I left, and it is worth noting how I felt on that occasion; it is revealing, of course, and in a way flattering to me. I was, naturally, unhappy to have proof that Rose had--in her intentions, anyway forsaken me. I felt as any young man would feel then. The platitude about it would include, as terms, both sorrow mid anger. Also I was lustful; that which I could not have, seemed gorgeous to me. So much is natural; what is hardly natural is this: that I worried about my successful rival, that I feared he might damage his noble prospects. This feeling as I remember it can still please me, for it implies an image of myself which has certain graceful extensions; but, more important, this feeling has meaning with respect to Orville. Not every man would concern me so. You are to understand that Orville was a man who caused his friends to conceive unusual responsibilities.
  ose, of course, had a different view of Orville as a responsibility. She had let him know the state of her feelings, she had shown her love, and now she was waiting to be taken. I believe she understood her responsibility to Orville to include one duty, that she be available, and no more. At the same time, she did not exclude me, partly because she was afraid that I might act jealously, and partly because she was cautious, so that she was unwilling to give up present comforts to future possibilities. Rose at all times dealt in facts, and so she slept with me now and then while she waited for Orville to make up his mind.
  he waited in vain, however. Orville would not betray Cassius, though he suffered greatly, and thus a most difficult and unhappy relation came to exist, a relation which I could see in all its fullness. Rose suffered sometimes from anger, and low spirits, and disgust, and could not avoid showing these emotions as she gave herself away in the beds we shared, and in the hay of a neighbor's barn. She was no longer completely mine, and sometimes I could sense what emotion or thought was dispossessing me.
  rville, after a time, got in the habit of visiting me at my office; thus I could see his unhappy state. He grew pale, in spite of his outdoor work. He lost weight, and otherwise languished, and, so Cassius told me, he lost interest in his Latin and his law, enough so that Cassius had become concerned.
  ne afternoon at the Courthouse, Cassius asked me to see if I could find out what was bothering Orville.
  It's a good boy and a fine mind," Cassius said in his straightforward fashion. "I wouldn't want to see him throw himself away. Look into it, will you? In my position it's a littIe hard . . ."
  t was not long before Orville was speaking to me in long parables, extended hypothetical examples, about the nature of ove, and about its causes, consequences, and cures; and so, it seemed to me, the difficult and unhappy relation reached its first climax there in my office. It is hardly strange that I was embarrassed and unhappy. That I responded coarsely, with references to Burton's Anatomy of Melancoly, with its shrewd and intricate remedies for Heroical Love! I spoke to Orville about the remedy of cucumber and hellabore, taken internally; and about the remedy of Much Venerie; and about that final remedy called Giving in; and forced the unhappy young man to laugh with me, because I kncw he would never admit that he was the sufferer who lingcred unhappily and staggered from Love's darts behind that false front of hypothesis.
  nd so it went. I could read in Rose's behavior and in Orville's conversation the progress of the affair. I could know the rogressive intensity of the private conversations which Rose arranged, which caused Rose such bewilderment, which caused in Orville so much white-lipped suffering.
  f this stage of affairs it is hardly necessary to speak at length. It is true, perhaps, that Orville might not have been badly hurt had he been more experienced with women, but he was as he was. He had known a girl or two at rodeo time I suppose; not more; not enough to acquire knowledge, and nowhere near enough to enable him to cope with a determined lust like that of Rose, and the kind of love which Rose could find in lust. Orville, at this stage, was defenseless, unable to avoid suffering. His great gifts were as nothing to him, though, as he once confessed to me, he had taken to reading Plutarch's Morals, in English translation, in an attempt to find relief. Quite simply, Orville was confronted with impossibilities. He could not remain himself and betray his friend Cassius; and he was moving in an atmosphere of suffering which might soon dissolve him.
  n one memorable night I saw Orville in the deeps of this harrowing love. There had been stories that he had not been taking care of his stock as he should. Neighbors had heard the milk cows bellowing late at night, for example, and one of his bulls had been roaming loose for three days. The stories came to me after a time, and it seemed wise one night to pay Orville a visit to see how he was faring. I had hopes of learning something; and I learned.
   found him drunk on the big bed in which he had been begotten, in which he had been born, in which he slept now, since his parents' death. A big plain bed of dark-stained walnut, it was, an heirloom from Missouri; it had a white cotton coverlet. He was fully dressed, down to his boots. His big Stetson was propped over his face in such a way as to cover his face, and he was very drunk, besotted, in fact, consciousness almost gone. When I reached him, he was gasping. It had been a great effort for him to speak loud enough to call me into the house.
  aturally, I was at a loss for a time, and finally found no better plan than to make coffee. This I did, over his protests, and he came around enough to talk to me, very plainly this time, without any hypotheses, without false fronts of any kind, though without using names; and this was, I believe, the turning point of his unhappy relation with my poor Rose. It seemed so at the time. Looked at from the present, from this dim and much-corroded eminence in time, it seems clearly so. It was the last hours of the original Orville.
  e asked me right away whether I knew a way to achieve sleep when a man is sick for love. Such were his words, and they made me uneasy in that high-ceilinged room. It was such a room as dignified Kansas farmers and their wives would have for sleeping and loving, in a house that might have been transplanted from the Middle West: hardly the place to speak about a man who was sick for love! And it was plain that Orville was a good housekeeper. The house was clean, and smelled clean, as white frame Gothic houses should smell. His mother's curtains hung in the windows, and this was a touching sight which caused me to remember Orville's innocence and made me sad. Plainly, Orville was niaintaining his mother's ways, in honor of her memory.
  ut at that moment Orville was alarmed by love. "The first thing I need is a cure for insomnia," he said. "Would you believe it? I've not slept for three days now, except for an hour I got yesterday afternoon under the pines in the yard. True. One hour of sleep in three days. What's a man to do?"
   felt guilty about the coffee I had made him drink, and said so. I was struggling with Orville's plight. I was trying to believe in it.
  Coffee won't wake me, and won't put me to sleep. I won't sleep tonight either, I know it." Then he explained his troubles, in detail, with a half-drunken eloquence which I admired; but saying the usual things, of course, the normal line through ancient sentences.
  -I've seen bulls in this fix, plenty of 'em. They'll groan, and beller, and wear a ditch alongside a fence, and grow poor, grow mighty poor while they're doing it-even grow sad, sometimes, I think! I've seen'em sad--they have ways of bellowing sorrow. But I've never had much feeling for 'em, somehow. I guess I've been wanting in sympathy, and it hurts my feelings to learn that. I've lost weight. Fifteen pounds it is now. And I've lost my color, and most of my strength, seems like. I haven't cared for Latin in over a month now, and I'd never have believed that that could happen to me. How in the world am I ever going to get any sleep?"
   little of this went a long way with me, and I began to believe in his plight. I felt a duty. The duty came down on me like a nightfall, and so I said the things I was able to say, the immemorial and immemorially ineffective propositions.
  Why bother so about a woman?" I asked him; and he shook his head to indicate that it was not in his power to change his yearnings.
  Why does the bull bother?" he said. "She told me she loves me. She breathes fast when she tells me, and she keeps the lights low. Once she even began to sweat a little, over the right temple. She did it, I swear, and, oh, it was fetching! Why can't you believe that? Didn't it ever happen to you?"
  hen I asked him why he did not simply give in and take her, and then do what he could afterward. "She's just a woman!" I said, while I felt much more than I spoke. "Take her. She's been asking for it! And remember, she'll hate you if you don't, mark my words, and she'll make you suffer for it. Why let a woman tear you apart? Why let a mere woman bother you?"
  Everything bothers me," he said then, with dignity, "or matters some way. I guess that's it. And of course I can't bring myself to hurt a friend. Can't do that. That's where the trouble lies. That's where, I'm afraid."
   fter a time I repeated myself, hoping that mere weight of words might have an effect; but then I gave up and left him, after first helping him to find the other bottle of whisky he had brought home with him. The next morning the milk cows bellowed again, far into the morning, and once again at night, so that the neighbors became almost angry with Orville; and it went so for almost a week, getting worse each day, until the neighbors began to speak of getting the town marshal out to speak to Orville. Throughout this period I was in troubled mind, and it was my conviction that something was about to happen.
  hat could a man do who was placed as Orville was placed, confronted so tangibly with formidable impossibilities? Poor Orville, he was truly caught. But it is true, alas, that any man will act, finally, when so pressed, and thus discover change--as Orville acted and discovered change. So it is that changes happen, I suppose; and who is to say that a man who suffers should not be allowed to find his way out of suffering? It would go hard with me to forbid the lost to try to find themselves.
  hat Orville did, however, was a surprise to me, and to others, though it was signaled by an event which seemed a happy one. On a Sunday morning a week or ten days after my talk with him Orville appeared bright and early at his barn to tend to his milk cows, on time at this chore for the first time in several weeks. He whistled and sang, so the story wcnt, and the neighbors felt called upon to spread the good Lord as quickly as possible, so that I heard it that morning at im, breakfast in the town restaurant. It was not until later, however, that the reasons for Orville's cheerfulness came out, and then there was some question about Orville's right to be cheerful. It developed after a time, and through the subtle digestive powers of town gossip, that Orville had a little disgraced himself on the Saturday night preceding his hippy Sunday morning; disgraced himself with a certain Elvira Almaver, in a haymow that belonged to Elvira's father, but, after the fashion of young men, gone home happy afterward.
  y the time I was amused and not quite convinced. A little later, however, I had reason to lose my amusement, as it became clear to me what course Orville had at last taken out of his troubles. For I believed that I had suggested that course to Orville, half jokingly but precisely; at least, I hurt myself with that allegation. To be brief, it became clear within the space of a month or six weeks after the affair of Elvira that Orville had had recourse to the most violent of Burton's remedies. He had plunged himself into Much Venerie; he had become a successful lover of young girls in our town, even of a few virgins, and in fact he had become for his contemporaries an amatory hero. Perhaps you can understand how easy it was for him: he was good enough looking, by town standards; he was a good cowboy, respected for his exploits with horses, ropes, wild cattle; he was an accepted hero, the conqueror of the Chinaman; and, most important, he was a man of ntelligence and great energy who needed only the exercise to learn device and stratagem in the wars of love.
  s far as I know, the only piece of equipment he bought was a buggy, and it is a gauge of our town's civilization in the twenties that Orville could still be fashionable in one. He was both fashionable and rakish. He had a little bay mare that he broke to the harness, and he kept her in fine condition. His harness had a fine glow to its leather, and a satisfyingly mild tinkling to its hardware. The buggy itself was a gleaming thing.
  leaming but, after a time, also infamous. There had always been a faint swagger of lordliness to Orville's ways; he walked high, and sometimes made sharp fun of fools. It was possible for him to receive a public favor with complete indifference if he disliked the giver, and he could court trouble and show temper, but all this seemed right and proper, or at least permissible, in him as he had been. Not with his buggy, however. With his buggy he became a little hard to take. What had been acceptable as fine intellectual qualities or high spirits in Orville's walks through town became something else when Orville was whipping his mare down the
main street; when he pulled up arrogantly to ask a girl to ride
with him. It was not long before the girls of the town understood what the buggy meant to them. It became known that a girl's honor rode, for better or worse, right beside her when shc accepted a ride in that buggy.
  t seems childish now, all that parade; but Orville had style. He could pop that buggy whip in a way to make small boys weep with envy and make their elder brothers turn away unhappily. He could make his mare pace, canter, and walk at the most imperceptible commands. He had buggy :rnd mare quite at his mercy. Some of the most pleasing images I carry now in memory are from the days of Orville's buggy, and are images of it. I remember the swanky, leather-and-horse smell of his arrival at an Elks' picnic with a pretty blonde girl whose family had just moved to town. I remember him in his cowboy uniform, seeing him leave a black-haired girl, the daughter of the town's only dentist, in the buggy behind the bucking chutes at the rodeo in the fall; leave her, make his way through the corrals, get down on a horse and come out in a fine ride on a wild bucker to win first prize for the day; and then gravely walk back to the buggy and drive out of the rodeo grounds, headed in the direction of Jackson's Grove.
  hat sort of thing; you can see how it might go. There
never any question about Orville's achievements, whatever they might be! He had a firm way of doing a job that helped people remember who had done it. Girls who had once enjoyed his favor rarely complained about him afterward. Most of them admitted freely that they still considered Orville a "good friend"; sometimes a girl even smiled when she said this, and then it was possible to guess with some justification that Orville had made a midnight call recently. In the space of six or seven months after the beginning of Orville's campaign it was generally agreed-among the young men, who knew a little, among the girls, who knew more, and among the expert gossips, who knew everything that really mattered--that Orville had conquered and otherwise had his will of eleven different girls, all young, all pretty, none of them of the easily vulnerable, too warmhearted kind. Naturally, it was alleged that some of these were virgins, and that two or three were pregnant as a result of Orville's labors.
  urton's remedy with a vengeance! It is worth mentioning that Orville admitted to me once, when we were both coming out of the county library, that he had indeed been thinking of Burton when he undertook his scheme. "It was do something or die of it," he said. "By God, it was. And so I did something. I'll keep on doing it until I don't need it, and do it right."
  t then occurred to me to ask whether he thought it was paying too much for the whistle--something clumsy of that sort, at any rate, and Orville did not much respect it. "To take a dozen women to get away from one, that doesn't sound very economical to me," I said. "I'm not trying to tell you what to do, Orville!"
  e answered me very soberly. "I made my choice," he said. "I haven't bothered any married women, and so now I'll do what I set out to do, and do everything that's supposed to be done. If a job's worth doing, it's worth doing well, isn't it?"
   comic revenge upon an unkind world, it was, and now and then I so regarded it; but, like any revenge, bound to have consequences. Given the situation, I knew what they would be, and it was a cause of pain that I was able to see my forcbodings embodied, day by day, in a thickening chronicle of facts. It was enough to make a moralist out of me--and did, in fact, after a time, when I had leisure to inspect the facts which had risen before me.
First of all, there were quarrels, unavoidably, with maddened fathers and with unlucky suitors. Orville avoided none of these. It became known very quickly that Orville was more than willing to fight anybody over the love of any young girl. It was plain in the bloodstained and battered look of his face and hands on too many occasions that he would compete with any father, with any lover. And since Orville was tough enough to win most of his fights, and stubborn enough to deny the fruits of victory when he lost, so that he returned again and again to places where he had been beaten, he caused many young men and many fathers to despair. But despair makes hate, and it was not long before Orville was well hated--a consequence I could not look at with any comfort.
  ext, there were indeed two pregnancies which Orville could have caused. It was rumored that Orville sold cattle to pay for the services of doctors in faraway cities; certainly his herd was diminishing noticeably. It began to be thought in the town that Orville was hardhearted, or that he wore an armor against virtuous thoughts, and this too caused hatred. I knew, of course, that Orville was in a way indulging a too secret love of virtue in his scheme of conquests, that he was attempting to avoid hurting his friend Cassius; but this was meek, small knowledge even in me as I confronted Orville's consequences; and no one else in the world knew it, so that it was quite without any helpful consequences of its own.
  nd then there was the matter of Orville's heroism, which was, for the town, chiefly a fact which existed in the collective mind of the town. I was there; it was possible for me to see the comic workings of the town's mind as that mind asked itself unpleasant questions. Was Orville's new effort a heroic effort? Was it quite the thing to be expected of a recognized hero? Was it quite the proper thing to follow the conquest of the Chinaman? Slowly the answers got themselves made. Slowly the town's mind came round to a decision. Strangely, in spite of the enmities which Orville had by that time built up, the decision was a gentle and fair one, and I was forced to share in it. The decision was disappointment in Orville himself, in what he had made of himself, in the way he had gone on from his great triumph; and the disappointment came with feelings of sadness.
    strange kind of justice! It was not long before I understood that Orville acquiesced in the town's decision; and his own disappointment appeared first as a kind of intellectual hesitation. He became a little hard to talk to.
  inally, of course, there was the reaction of Rose, my Rose and Cassius's Rose. This I had foreseen; it gave me a muted pleasure to see how accurately. Rose very quickly came around to hating Orville. At about the time Orville was attempting his third conquest--of a girl Rose knew, a soprano in the Methodist church choir which Rose frequented as a contralto--Rose required Cassius to forbid Orville the house. She announced her grounds clearly: that Orville was a disgrace, a ruined young man, not fit for decent company. She was very firm. Cassius was so upset that he came to me with the story and asked me to arrange with Orville for lawand-Latin meetings in my office. This I did, but of course in a little while word of the arrangement reached Rose. I could then tell from Cassius's face that she was making him smart for it. And of course I had direct ways of discovering Rose's feelings.
  aturally, she did not speak to me about Orville, for Rose
was never brazen, but she became suddenly warmer to me as
she became cooler to Orville. That was an intense time in my
life. We became less friendly and more passionate, and thus I
was able to learn something about the nature of lust, about
the nature of love. We had such fierce and sweaty struggles
as no man could forget, and it disturbs me yet that I could sense in Rose's fury a desire to cuckold poor Orville in some final way. Sometimes, nowadays, I wonder how I knew that savage little fact which beat away there at the heart of our Irrst; but I knew. One knows. It takes only a warning to waken perception, and I had had plenty of warnings from Itose. It was often my idea of her that she could be comfortable with a revenge.
  hus, for the time being, Rose; but it was Cassius who suffcrcd more painfully than anyone else in town because of Orville's wild lecheries. His sorrow, I suppose, was the most grievous consequence of Orville's actions, and it exposed ranges of feeling in him which I could never have guessed at. During one of the law-and-Latin meetings in my office, I remember, Cassius appeared almost half an hour early, clearly in order to speak to me; he began speaking immediately after he arrived. Standing there in my office-which was also my living room when I was off duty--he was a tall heavy figure in his black suit, bald, with a tough middle-aged face and a deep, chest-resounding voice. All in all, not the kind of man I would expect to confess despair.
  There's something I want to do," he said. "But I don't know what it is. I can't seem to find it. The town is getting aroused, man. Look at my poor Rose, how she carries on! By God, something will have to be done, that's all there is to it. We'll have to find something and do it."
   said I agreed, but that I was bewildered, and that it might be foolish to talk to Orville. "You can't talk to a tomcat," I said. "Any more than to a wildcat."
  It's that he's such a fine boy!" Cassius said. "It's the best and smartest boy that ever I knew, and I love him like a son. Can't you see how it makes me feel to see him fall so far short of himself? God damn those willing little girls!"
  e was in a rage; he was also near to tears, and so he stood before me a fine image of anger contending with sorrow. So might Orestes once have stood after hearing about Aegisthus, so Hamlet before the ghost; and it was a quality he had there in my office, in that dim and shrouded place, that he seemed almost an image of uncorrupted youth; and thus I learned something about him. I learned that he had not yet given in to time and the world. He remained, in some deep part of him, the virtuous young man he had once been, remained even a little naive, and this was a comfort to me. His head had grown bald, his voice rough with whisky and cigars, but some essential part of his goodness had resisted change. Extravagant language, almost, for discussing a man who could not even keep his wife away from young men, but true language; that was the way I found him.
  I'm going to be drunk," he said. "I swear to God I'm going to be drunk for the first time since the war. I can't stand it, I tcll you."
  or a while I was afraid that he might not conduct himself properly during the meeting with Orville; but of course he did conduct himself properly, at great cost, with great pain, but with dignity and politeness, and with that assurance that can come only to a good man in difficult chances. I came to admire him that night, and it was a discovery. Surprise and wonder happened to me--to a mind made clear by shock; and a little later there were consequences.
  t was a small consequence, however, that I was able to make from it; a costly one to me but really helpful to no one else. A week or so later I gave up Rose, or began to. I had to discover what I already knew, that Rose was not easily got rid of, but I began my attempt, and took my beating, and had a kind of success after a time.
  efore that success, however, and after a campaign of some ten or eleven months, Orville gave up his career as a lover of young girls. He sold his buggy and the buggy's harncss; the mare went back under the saddle; and the news of these events spread rapidly, traveling in stories which often involved laughter. Once again Orville resumed his old habit of coming to town only once a week, for his law-and-Latin meeting with Cassius. He was polite to the girls he knew, but formal--he treated them like cousins from faraway towns.
  aturally, there was a sensation in the town, as there always must be when a rake reforms. At first there was distrust. Young men and a few fathers were heard to say that Orville was planning some monstrous new seduction. The name of the choir leader of the Baptist church, a married woman, was mentioned, and for a week this woman's cheeks were flushed with the scandal. After distrust came a period of mourning, for there were some, both women and men, who had admired Orville's style. These saw in Orville's withdrawal something like the death of youth, and I heard rumors of sentamental tears.
  nd then came acceptance. There began to be general agreement that Orville had returned to himself. His exploit ith the Chinaman was recalled. People who had not spoken to him for months made a point of seeking him out, and it was not long before the town had once again arranged a place for Orville as the town hero.
  rville himself was visibly unhappy; properly unhappy as it seemed to the town, and thus the reconciliation reached a formal close.
  The plain truth is," Orville told me once when I went out to his ranch to see him, "that I just don't care any more. I suffer from ennui. I don't feel bad, you understand, but I'm awful tired of girls."
It was another strange occasion at Orville's ranch. I had found him, in the evening, asleep in a hammock strung up between two of his pines. "My trouble now is that I can't stay awake," he told me a little while after I waked him. "I've been sleeping all day after sleeping all night, and I feel pretty sleepy now. I get up to milk the cows, that's about all. Sometimes I don't move an eyelid for hours."
  t was a shock for me, I can tell you. I knew very well what ennui was, for I had lived some bad days in it, but I could hardly bring myself to believe that Orville could ever fall into it. He had had such energy and such calm; I remembered that serene liberation of his energies in one task after another which had for so long been his distinguishing feature.
  I know what ennui is," I said, "and I'm sorry to hear that you do."
   stood there in front of the tidy white frame house and wondered at the pace of change. It was a smallish house, half hidden but not obscured by the dark pines; its kind are still to be found, by thousands, under cottonwoods or pines or maples, throughout the farmlands of the Middle West, standing upright and firm as places for families and children, with the wheat going away on all sides in a massive, gleaming light. A steep white house; and ancient boxes and peeling, cracked old trunks stood in the high narrow darkness of the attic; this Orville had told me; and it was likely that old love letters moldered and grew yellow in forgotten corners of those
trunks and boxes--in dusty pent-up air which might still be fragrant with rose petals treasured up in Mason jars.
  he past was in that house, and it was a gracious past. As I watched the house, I thought about such things as ice-cream socials held in the grounds of a church, with the men decorously taking care of the freezers, and the children hovering near and uttering shrill fierce cries; of picnics memorialized in sun-smeared snapshots, with the women wearing sweeping hats with brims like sails that wavered in wind and grazed the long dark hair of the women who wore them; and of family reunions, those stately celebrations of passing time and of death growing into families--happening always in the best picnic grove in the county, under cottonwoods likely, with buggies and horses at the edge of the grove, with the children straying, getting lost, and the parents gravely mourning the dead.
  rville's house was a house for old-fashioned people, and it was a shock for me to consider that; for Orville in his way was old-fashioned, a true son to his dead parents. He belonged to that house, and knew the allegiances which it imposed, and I could see these facts as qualities grained into his whole character, the course of his whole life; and yet he was at the same time a famous seducer, and now suffered from painful sophistications of a disease which his ancestors could never have known. He was suffering from ennui, no oldfashioned disease for his kind of people, by his own confesion, and by the plain evidence of his loose, dulled relaxation with the gentle swinging motion of the hammock, as if the hammock imitated the swaying of his dazed and sleepy mind.
His will suffered, that was the fact of it, and a kind of horror came to me as I considered what Orville's ancestors would have had to say about such suffering, because it was likely that Orville would now say the same things to himself. Those ancestors would have called him lazy and said no more, and their contempt would have fallen on him. It did not help me that I knew Orville was not lazy; it did not make me happy to see a disease of the will.
  I feel empty," Orville said. "I lie here in this hammock and I feel light as a feather. Comes up a little wind, why, it just ripples me a little and goes right on by. I lie here and forget where I am. I sleep and sleep and never dream at all. Is that what you know about ennui?"
  t was close enough to what I knew. I grew uncomfortable, and left soon, Orville having told me, called to me from his hammock as I departed, that he joked but was not amused by his joking.
"It's no laughing matter!" he called. "Never mind the things I say!"
   learned a few days later from Cassius that Orville had still not quite come up to himself in his Latin, but Cassius was not much concerned about that. He was happy to have Orville back. He pronounced a triumph over the willing little girls.
  Women have a place," he said. "Now let 'em remember what it is! "
   saw Orville, after that, each time he came to my office for his meetings with Cassius, and I was able to observe some little changes in him. Little but not unimportant: new kinds of knowledge had touched his character here and there, and marked him. Where once he had happened before my eyes with a kind of purity, kindled from one moment to the next, he now came blurred a little, a little spotted. Any man is a number of faces, of masks, but once Orville's masks had formed an imposing continuity which had often left me dazed, which had always made me happy, sure that I watched a better man; but no more. The innocence was gone, and something else was gone with it: Orville now was a stained man like any other.
  Once I wanted to be a hero," he told me one night. "A kind of town hero, but not only that--you know what I mean. Now I think I'd be happy just to have my strength back. Why, do you know, there was a time when I wanted to be president, and when I knew I could be a good senator if I wanted to."
   guessed that Orville would not remain in his state of let hargy; I could not believe that ennui would hold him for long; but it held him. After a time I felt that consent was involved in Orville's miseries, that he had agreed to ennui, and I came to the idea that he was waiting for something to happen. There was a strange quality to Orville's idleness. I knew the idle surface, which the wind rippled, and I had a sense of empty depths, abysmal silences; but I also had a sense, confirmed in ways I never understood, of hidden, close-kept eagerness. Eager anticipation was there. That part of Orville which was most alive was waiting for something to happen, And I was frightened to notice, alongside that waiting, a cold willingness to accept what might come.
   believed that Orville was vulnerable then as never before; for who can tell what might come? In the interest of the right, in hopes of escaping an offense against a friend, Orville had chosen to commit a lesser wrong--or what had seemed a lesser wrong, and now, presumably, there were weeping girls in the town of Albo. The question which held me then, and holds me now, is what their weeping did to Orville.
  I'm short of confidence just now," he told me at one of our conferences. "It's hard for me to believe that I know what I'm doing. Did you hear that Mary Ellen Board has left town? Last week. Left her home and family. A thing I don't like is that she told me she'd do that if I quit her. Now I wonder how she'll be in Los Angeles. You see? I'm losing my confidence."
  omething had happened to Orville's powers of judgment, that was clear. His sense of the right had become a little confused.
  So I just lie in my hammock waiting," he said. "I have a feeling for time now. It's like something I eat, something that becomes a part of me. A funny thing is that it doesn't have any weight at all. But I know it's there, and I'm a glutton of it. I wonder what will happen next."
  mall wonder that I was saddened.
  I've taken to watching sunrises and sunsets from my hammock," Orville said. "They remind me that there's plenty of time outside me still."
  e had a lively fancy, Orville, and he used it to amuse me, but I was only a little amused. I was busy trying to escape Rose; a hard job, and an unpleasant one because it was impossible for me to explain my real motives to her. How could I tell her that I no longer wished to betray her husband? But I was trying. One of my devices was to call on Cassius in the evenings, as in the past when I had come to make arrangements with Rose, but on these occasions I stayed with Cassius and talked to him. And so it happened that when Cassius admitted me one night, with a fine big smile on his face, and showed me into the parlor, Rose and Orville were sitting there: a duplicate to that scene I remembered from the past, when I had so clearly witnessed Rose showing her love to Orville. Cassius was happy. He was eager, like a boy, and he could hardly wait to get me into the library with him so that he could whisper his bright new secret to me. "I got her to let him come back in the house--yesterday it was! I've been at her and at her ever since Orville reformed, but she just wouldn't have it. I swear to God there's nothing like a woman up in arms about a moral question, nothing in the world! And she's still got her dander up, and no mistake. My poor Rose is not the one to let a feud die out without making the other party suffer for it. But I told Orville what the story was, and now he's on his best behavior, and I believe it'll work out. By Joe, I knew I had a right to have confidence in that boy!" There was more such talk as Cassius poured the bourbon, and the talk left me a little dazed. Cassius offered me a cigar, and as I lighted it, he said triumphantly: "By the living God, it's something to reclaim a fine boy from lechery! I'm almost willing to be drunk for joy!"
  hen we returned to the parlor, I found a tableau which reassured me. Rose sat bolt upright on a straight-backed chair, with her knitting in her lap; she was silent, and it was possible to sense in the atmosphere of the room that she had been silent since we had left it, or nearly so; and she was showing anger, mainly by a vicious way she had of clicking her knitting needles together. Orville was uncomfortable, plainly, but not so uncomfortable as I might have liked. There was something sour, a little sick, in that scene, and it seemed to me then that it came straight from Orville's condition of qualified poise. Had he been as before, red-necked and boyish and fumbling in his speech, I could have happy; but as he sat there in the parlor, saying nothing except to questions from Cassius, and looking at the pattern in the old carpet, he reminded me of the Orville who had whipped his fine mare down the main street in the traces of a gleaming buggy.
   was alarmed. I had every reason to be afraid, and I knew the kind of trouble that might come; but nothing happened that night, nor during the days that followed, and my fears were lulled. I was busy with my efforts to shake off Rose, and it happened that some two or three weeks after Orville's reconciliation with Rose's house I was finally able to win from Rose a statement that she would let me go. It did not come in such a plain form as that, of course. It amounted only to this, that she would not mind if we canceled an appointment we had made long since to celebrate in a neighbor's hay our second anniversary. That was all. It was enough, and I was free.
  or perhaps a week I was in no mood for anything but celebrations, and so I rioted in my folly, getting drunk twice, and going once to Carson City for two nights and a day of gambling. As I have said, I had come to respect Cassius, and at that time in my life it was cause for joy when I could show that kind of respect, even when I was obliged to show it in deep privacy. When I returned from Carson City, still feeling free, and feeling also mildly irresponsible because I had lost most of my money, it seemed a natural thing to visit Orville and to attempt cheering him up.
Thus, when I found Orville in no need of cheering up, found him busy and active over books when I visited him in the evening, with no hammock strung up between the pines, I was in just that state of foolishness which enabled me to rejoice with him in his deliverance from ennui. I asked him whether he was still a glutton of time; and he told me that he was not.
  I don't have to be, any longer," he told me. "Something has happened to time. It's slowed up, somehow, hardly moving any more. To tell the truth, I've forgotten all about it. I don't even look at the sunrises and sunsets any more!"
  e had such foolery for perhaps an hour before I went home, and that night I slept a foolish sleep.
  he next day I met Cassius at the Courthouse in the normal way--we both had business there--but to no normal end.
That was a rarity, a true meeting; an accident in which two people arrive in understanding at the same place, or happening, without having time to put up defensive masks.
  hen I first saw him, Cassius was standing at the top of the front steps to the Courthouse. He was leaning into the shadow of one of the wooden pillars.
   spoke to him, but he only nodded, and for a moment I suffered a brief flare-up of fear, thinking that I had been discovered at last in my crimes against him. But then I noticed that he was not really seeing me.
  I'm sorry," he said after a moment. "I didn't sleep well last night."
  is face was no good for hiding emotion. It was possible for me to pierce the shade in which he held his head. I was able to know something about Cassius that I had never expectcd to know: he was suffering from suspicion, and it hurt him. He was not a man to be much bothered by suspicion in the normal order of his life, but now, plainly, there had been an interruption of the normal order of his life. In a clear moment we had our meeting, and what he knew, I guessed; guessed what had happened while I lurched miserably from folly to folly. Rose and Orville: the bad thing, the almost inconceivable thing, now made to seem an almost inevitable thing; Rose and Orville, at long last, and in spite of Orville's efforts . . .
   became a little dizzy as I stood in front of the shadow which held Cassius. I was in bright sunshine, pouring down wn me, as I remembered the sudden ease of my last parting from Rose, as when the last stitch in an old cut pulls out at last, causing no twinge of pain; as I remembered the relaxation of Orville's ennui; as I confronted Cassius's suspicion. "Cassius will have been warned against Orville by Orville's own doings," I thought, "and because he loves Orville he'll understand him as he'd never understand me or Rose or me and Rose together."
   did a strange thing then, which I believe was no mere weakness. I closed my eyes, and blinked, and wept a little, there in broad daylight. I was wearing a hat, and I bent my head down, so that I was no obvious public spectacle, but I believe that Cassius noticed what was happening. He was the kind of man who did not miss such things; a generous heart will wince at others' tears. He began talking, in spite of his own burgeoning sorrow, and in a moment I had recovered myself. He continued talking long enough for me to mop my brow--and eyes--with my handkerchief before he departed.
  Rose is waiting for me," he said gravely. "If anyone asks for me, tell them that I will be in my office later this afternoon." Then he left me, heading home. He walked with his back straight in the black coat, an old-fashioned gentleman of the middle years, going away from me.
  t was a searing moment. To its intensities I attribute my actions for the rest of the day, and my failures; for that was a day black with failure. From that day I learned that some kinds of failure are wicked and obscene, a lesson which the years have reinforced.
Naturally, I went from the Courthouse to Orville, finding him at work on a gate near his barn, and I wasted no time in coming to the point. I was angry, and my anger felt sanctified because I nursed it in the name of another man, of Cassius. I had some of the coldness which all agents have, and a good deal of that serenity which comes with dedication. I felt free to say anything, because I was not speaking for myself.
  rville was cheerful, glad to see me, and energetic about that gladness, so that I could know he had had some of his certainties recently refreshed. He could afford to be kind to me because he felt secure, and thus I was able to shock him quite easily.
  God damn it, Orville," I said, "I want you to turn loose of Rose Martin, and just as quick as you can do it."
  hat must have been the first time Orville had ever been
kept from action by mere words. Certainly I could see that he wanted to act: in an instant he was ready to fight, and I briefly regretted the switch-blade knife I had not thought to bring with me that morning. But in that same instant when he became ready to fight, even to try killing me, something else happened to him that made fighting, or any action, impossible to him. What, precisely, I don't expect to know, but I suspect that it was a feeling of chill, of coldness driven into Imme; that feeling of dismay which sometimes comes with unwelcome knowledge. He did not move, and for a long time did not speak. I had him at my mercy.
  I don't understand why you did it, Orville," I said, and it pleased me that he flinched while I did not. "Any man is liable to a little unexpected rutting now and then, and you've had your share of that. But you knew what was at stake with Rose. God damn it, man, Cassius is your friend!"
  omething changed in his face, and I had the feeling that he was remembering. His face sickened, and he grew pale. I had seen the same expression on the faces of men who are on the point of drinking too much whisky.
  And you struggled for so long, Orville, and paid so high, to stay away from her. Good Lord, have you forgotten the twelve or eleven girls, and the two or three virgins, and the two pregnancies? To throw it all away at last!"
 Sit down," Orville said then. He sank to the ground and rested his back against the fence, and there was something in this movement, something of spirit gone slack, of dullness returning, which unmanned me. There was my victory, slumped on dusty earth, propped against a board fence, and it was more victory than I had bargained for. At about this moment, when I was already beginning to suffer, I was reminded of my own false position, as by the workings of a god of justice. There in that hot light I learned another lesson, that hypocrisy can be most virulently painful. It is a sickness, like any other; but its fever and chills warp the mind, not the body, and make the soul giddy.
  Christ help us all," I said. "I'm sorry, Orville." I sat down beside him. After a while he began to talk.
  I keep forgetting myself," he said. "As if I were a child, and I were my own toy, left somewhere under a bush." At that moment his words seemed just; he had the look, in the way his body slumped against the board fence, of a wrecked toy, a battered doll; he was not a small man, but now he looked small. Plainly, he had forgotten himself in the pain which had found him, and now he was merely present against the board fence, not in any way active there. He looked the way human bodies look when they are hurt--in the newspaper photographs this would be the white blur of a man's shirt alongside the wreckage of a car, or the jagged light and dark of a woman's ripped dress beside the same wreckage.
  is awareness of himself was gone--of the way he touched or owned or loved the little world he knew. There was a faintly dazed look about his eyes, and it was impossible for me to see in him the old heroic idea I had had of him. He looked sad and confused, and I remembered the face of a welterweight boxer I had once seen; just so the boxer's face had been, the brain clouded by blows, the clouds showing in the blurred look of the face. The thought came to me that for Orville, too, it was beginning to be hard to recognize in himself the old heroic idea.
  nd then he began to come back a little. I sensed a considerrable effort, and I knew he was struggling. He did not change his position, except to straighten one leg, but there was a difference in his appearance. It came to me after a time that he was no longer relaxed against the board fence, that now he was holding himself, drawing slack muscles tight. Some part of his dignity returned. Intelligence was at work almost visibly in him, compelling his attention to the fact that he must live and move. "I spend a lot of time these days looking under bushes for that toy," he said. "Not quite what I'd expected to be doing at this age. I guess I told you once how I thought I could make a president, and knew I could be a senator. That's the way I used to think. A senator or a Supreme Court judge, that was about the bottom of my plans; that I'd settle for if I had an accident--say, if I went blind. I used to think about the library I'd have. There'd be leathercovered chairs, and my lawbooks bound in calfskin. You can see what I had in mind. Cato or Brutus in an American lawyer's library, and the country waiting for what I had to say. Well, I could still think that way, I guess. I do, in fact, I do some of the time, because I have a notion of what I could do." He spoke calmly, gently, as if to a child; as if to himself. When he paused, he shook his head.
  So much for that," he said. He pulled his hat down over his eyes and straightened his body; he had all his dignity back by now, and he looked more like the Orville I had known. In a clear voice he made a little speech: "I didn't love her. After about the fifth girl from town I stopped loving her. And I didn't want her. There's plenty better looking in town, and a few I know that have a better action, if it comes to that. True. All that's true. And of course she doesn't have anyhing to say. She only likes the sound of Latin, or the men's voices saying it.
  But she hated me. That, or seemed to. How could I tell the difference, with a woman I hardly knew? She said she hated me: the first time I went back to her house, while you and Cassius were in the library. 'I hate you, Orville Ledyard,' she said. 'I hate you with a pure cold hate, and I'll make you feel it.' Can you imagine that? It didn't help my feelings any, I can tell you.
  Nobody likes to be hated. I never have, I've always tried to stay away from that. Well, I showed myself that I could do without her love, but I never yet learned how to get along with a woman's hate, and that's about where the trouble started, because I knew I had a remedy. You know what remedy--I've never yet seen it fail. You see, I'd learned a few things from the girls in town, and learned a few things about myself, so I knew I didn't have to let her hate me. Knew it!
  And then there was the problem aspect to it. I guess I never tried before to get a woman who hated me. And I was bored, remember. I had that ennui--it is a fact that I suffered from it. I'd been waiting for something to happen when she told me that she hated me, and that seemed like what I'd been waiting for. Something happened, anyway.
  What I'm remembering now, what I've been remembering since you came, is that as soon as she started giving in, and even while she was about it--and don't think that isn't a game she knows the ins and outs of--I was regretting it all. She didn't really hate me, of course. That was just her come-on. She's not really very ignorant about the way these things work. So that I had a hold of her, but was thinking about Cassius. I was thinking that I never liked another man half so well, saving my own father, and Cassius has been like a father to me. It makes a story, doesn't it?"
 mmediately I asked him why he did not instantly quit her, leave her, drop her, cut her dead, and for a moment I felt I had the answer to my woes. But he would not do it. It was not in his bargain with her to act in that fashion.
  It's up to her," he said. "I'm going to try to keep the faith with her, if with no one else."
  nd that was the way I had to leave it. For a time I considered telling him about my connection with Rose, in hopes of causing him to feel disgust with her, so that he would leave her; but I could not bring myself to it. It was not possible to me, and I left Orville with a feeling that I perhaps loved that poor tormented girl more than any man living could love her.
  ot the best state of feeling for one who wished to negotiate with her. When I left Orville, I had made up my mind to speak to Rose, and to ask her to give Orville up, to yield him up to the simpler life he had known before she had caught him.
  nd so I made arrangements. I sent a boy to Cassius's office with a request for a book--a lawbook, of course, because I wanted the illusion of solemn business--and when the boy rcrurned with the book I knew that Cassius was safely away f rom home. The boy told me, in addition, that there were two clients waiting patiently in Cassius's outer office. Then I walked to the Martin house and knocked at the front door. I was a friend of the family, but I would soon be alone with the wife.
  ose was at home. She admitted me with a smile, and it wis not long before I knew that she was glad to see me. She wanted someone to talk to, that was part of it; there were some things she could discuss only with me, and this fact was a bond. Also, I think, in some way she still loved me, and my sense of this was as warm in the room as Rose herself, as the woman who stood pale and faintly provoked before me. I discovered then that I still loved her, and thus we achieved a frightening kind of tension even before we spoke.
   was for some time unable to speak. It is not easy to return to a once-loved woman. The fact of love is there in her person, and it is only history that hurts; and history can be forgotten for a little while.
  he took me to the parlor and gave me lemonade. She drank tea from a little silver pot, and smiled steadily at me.
  It's so good to have you back," she said, raising her hand as if to prevent protests. "For lemonade, for talk. You understand. Sometimes this is a very lonely house." She was wearing a house dress of some lightweight but dark-colored material--something near a brown; and for a moment, while she succeeded in looking lonely, the dress seemed to be her body, and her body had a thick, impending presence which seemed very close to me; heavy of thigh, shoulder, hip. She became more alive than she had been, in an instant, troubling old desire, but somehow forcing me away; caused me to sense within her body the life which held her there, but, when she smiled, caused me to sense mortality as if I were breathing it like air. That was a life so intensely living that it made me think of death, and so I stood stock-still and was almost afraid until the moment passed.
  he no longer bothered to look lonely. Her dark eyes, glistening at me, controlled the woman she had chosen to become, and she was suddenly austere and slender, an elegant figure posing for me in an isolation which from moment to moment she spun out of her own being. She was drenched in distance, by her own choosing, and far away in light; restless sunlight crisscrossed the room from the windows. She looked handsome at that moment, after the fashion of women in furs on a well-darkened winter street. Pretty women look so when they are remote from the men who watch them. "I won't even ask you to explain why you came back," she said.
  hat room was haunted for me. There were heavy drapes over the narrow windows, drapes tall enough to hide a man, and once I had hidden myself in them while Cassius, on an unexpected errand, looked for a paper in the next room. Ghosts were there in that parlor; they were the lovers we had been, where we had kissed, where I had made comic purcuits of her, where she had been waiting for me on the sofa onee winter afternoon, naked and radiant, with a red paper rose in her hair to remind me of happy summer days. It was hard for me to speak; I was thinking unhappily of Cassius.
  I have business, Rose," I said uncomfortably. "There's something I want to talk to you about."
  I understood that you came to talk," she said. "For a visit. That's natural enough."
  he was cool, and I was not. I had the feeling that she was enjoying herself. It came into my mind as a kind of revelation that I must be careful about speaking out to her, and must be careful about mentioning Orville's name, for I had discovered somehow, in the way she held herself, in the way she controlled her voice, that she was waiting for me, primed in those matters which most concerned me.
  I came to see how you are," I said, "how you're getting on."
  My health is good," she said. "I had a cold last week, but it's all gone now. I have a little headache in the afternoons, but usually goes away with tea."
  I'm glad. You deserve good health, Rose. But I wasn't so much worried about your health. I'm concerned about you. It was a wretched start, likely to end itself before I could begin to control it, but it had an effect which I could observe. Rose colored a little. I think she allowed her face to color, but then she must have wished me to understand something by it. I believe she wanted me to know that I could still affect her, that she was not unmoved by my presence there in that haunted room. She may even have intended me to remember the red paper rose.
  I worry about you, Rose. I haven't seen much of you lately."
  t this she moved her lips in a way she had, turning the corners down, and closing her eyes at the same time. This meant anger, but only a mild anger, which in the past she had used only to give piquancy to her features. Now I was not sure. I was confused, unable to think of anything to say. After a long and well-calculated moment she spoke, this time firmly, with a kind of prim violence.
  You want to know if I've been faithful to you, isn't that it?"
  That's not it, Rose!"
  Well, I haven't been, and I don't mean to be in the future, and that's that. Would you like to go home now?"
  he rose from her chair, clutching her saucer in one hand and her teacup in the other. She seemed angry and unhappy, and she appeared to be suggesting that she was charmingly bewildered. She allowed herself the scowl of a little girl; she blinked back tears.
  That doesn't mean that I don't still love you," she said.
She began to weep, and in a little while it seemed right for me to console her. I touched her hair, above the right ear, where she had been working on a new curl, and spoke softly to her. She wept for a time against the lapels of my coat, but only long enough to make a minor reconciliation, when it came, seem natural. We were familiar with each other; the feeling must have been like that of a silver wedding anniversary.
  You're so mean," she said. "You make me hate you."
  I'm not," I said. "But then I can't let you tyrannize."
  Oh, you! You haven't changed a bit!"
  uch talk passed enough time for us so that we could safely, with emotions under control, go on to more interesting and more important matters. Characteristically, it was Rose who made the transition.
  I'd be so glad to have you back," she said. "Really I ,would! I can't come in this room without thinking about you."
  Forsaking all others?" I asked. "Would I be the only one?"
  The only one."
  And no diversions? No games?"
  Just you. Just old you, the way we've always been."
   knew I would reject her. In my mind as I spoke to her,was the idea, jacketed in thick feeling, that my health as a nnan, and even my sanity, depended on freedom from her; and on a freedom achieved, not on a dismissal given. It is hard now to understand the intensity of that idea and those feelings, but I can still bring them back, have them again in memory, and they are like a nausea. Thus, as I penetrated Rose's proposal to take me back, with its clear implication that she would then let Orville go, I found dizzying hazards in my way. Oddly, for me, I had an opportunity to be a hero of sorts, and knew it: a hero of the self-sacrificing variety, yielding up the best and strongest part of myself to the interists of others.
   reflection I avoid these days has to do with the shuddering violence of my withdrawal from that heroism, that selfsacrifice. I made no loud sounds, but the violence was there, all of it inside, and the more painful for being so ruthlessly contained. Even at the time I was smitten, baffled, by the fact that I was in a position to avoid heroism--that so high duty--in the name of honest morality.
To myself I said: "I can't betray Cassius again. I can't betray Cassius again"; while to Rose I said: "I'm sorry, my dear, but I'm afraid it's impossible."
  he was not surprised or even angry, so it seemed, and she asked for no explanations, so that I was left unpropped in my stanchly moral state; but she was prepared. She had the alternatives neatly worked out. In that power politics of the emotions which we were so intensely playing, she moved precisely within the cruel limits of her knowledge. Like Metternich, she knew all the boundaries, all the internal combinations, all the pretenders, and, like him, she knew what she wanted.
  I knew you wouldn't," she said. "Of course you understand that you won't have any claims on me? From this instant. I don't mean to be unfriendly, but I want you to understand. I must do what I can for my little troubles, by myself--tea for the headache, the smell of coffee for my sinuses. I so want you to understand. Do you understand?"
  he watched me closely, and for the occasion she wore the most sober of her masks: that one reserved for the times when she wished to show attention to a man who impressed her. Her eyes showed concern, her mouth, wonder; and it will be with me to the end of my life that somehow, by some artifice twisted into the set of her shoulders and her head, she contrived to show love.
  We do understand?" she said.
  We understand," I said, "though I'll be damned if I like it, Rose. Why can't you-"
 Tut," she said. "You must remember that I'm a married lady."
  hus my failure with Rose, a more grievous failure than my failure with Orville, and one which had almost immediate consequences.
  he very next day, which was an unusually cold day in late April, with a clear brilliant sun, Cassius, my friend and colleague Cassius Martin, drove Orville Ledyard from the Strccts of Albo with a buggy whip; drove him from one end of the main street to the other, out of town, and half a mile along the road to Orville's ranch; drove him in no usual way, it is true, but drove him nonetheless. The abused husband took revenge. Half the town came out to gape and watch.
  ust how the timing of these events happened will remain a mystery to me, I am sure. It is possible that Rose, angry with me and with Orville, and wishing a revenge upon us and upon Cassius as well, may simply have told Cassius that Orvillc had most villainously and skillfully seduced her, using arts learned in his conquests of the town girls, against her will but beyond her powers of resistance; something like that, some clumsy lie effectively garnished with tears and deep, horribly racking sobs. This is possible, not likely.
  r it may have been that Itose, without ever speaking, showed her guilt; left its traces in the way she talked at the dinner table, and polished the silver, and washed the dishes; in the way she cleaned house, and in the way she put on her nightgown--in any of those places and moments of the married life which can be a ground for perception. She could have suffered from a guilty conscience without being able to speak of it; she could have been longing, unhappily, forr peace, for an emotional calm. Again, this is possible, not likelv. Rose in those days was a lively, happy woman. I cannot it believe that she wanted change badly enough to work
for it.
  t is my notion that the relationship of Rose and Orville, being not quite so coldhearted as my relation with Rose, and never so fully under the control of self-interest, never so vulnerable to the censorship of strong vanities, was simply more visible than my relationship with Rose had been. It was more there; it had a more virulent and pungent existence. Like a day at the circus, it had an air of spontaneity, an almost visible exuberance, and it may be that in the Martin house it was both visible and palpable. Poor Cassius may have felt it in his fingertips, in raised hair at the back of his neck, and there seen it like a ghost walking the halls. In any event, he found out about it, and took action. Having been fooled once, and for a long time, he was not fooled again. It may be that there is a power which sees to it that decent husbands are not fooled over and over again.
  nd so we had that memorable day, an astonishing day in Albo, one which few people there to have it and know it will ever forget. It was like a pageant invented to instruct and amuse the people, and it had a quality as of pageant, or show, in the contrived sadness of its close.
  t began in the lobby of the Courthouse at about ten in the morning. There Cassius called a boy in from the porch and told him to go out to the Ledyard ranch for Orville and ask him to come into town, to Cassius's office, by noon. Cassius made no secret of it. He gave the boy a quarter, and the boy scampered. So much I saw, and no more, and Cassius did not speak to me, but what I saw was enough to put me on guard, and I took care to be near Cassius's office that noon, in a place where I could see what happened. I was afraid. There had been trouble, there could be more.
  ut when Orville arrived, Cassius greeted him mildly from the door of his office and went out to shake hands after Orville got down from his horse; the horse was the bay mare that once had pulled the gleaming buggy. To the point of shaking hands, the scene could have been nothing more than a meeting between friends. After they shook hands, it changed, for Cassius then asked Orville, in a clear voice, a little louder than I could quite believe: "Well, son, I called you in to ask you if you've been sleeping with my wife. That's all. Nothing more than that. How about it?"
  here was a silence. After such questions, such silences come easy to anyone in range, and by this time, I noticed, there were two or three people stopped within range of Cassius's voice; stopped very sharply, their heads set perplexedly like the heads of deer caught in strong light after dark, with just that quality of mute, animal-like wonder in their eyes.
  Think it over, son," Cassius said. "You know I wouldn't ask you a thing like that if I didn't mean something by it."
  rville did not move. He stood there in stained blue shirt and blue levis and boots, his face dark under his big hat. His head was bent forward; I could not see the expression of his face. After a time he spoke, very softly, as if he were afraid to be heard.
  I can't deny it," he said. "I'd lie if it'd do any good."
  I know you would, son. I know how it is. But I guess I can't bring myself to like it much. Excuse me, will you?"
  rville nodded his head, very slightly, and otherwise did nor move while Cassius entered his office and came back quickly with a buggy whip in his hand. Both were oblivious the slowly gathering crowd.
  I guess you know what this is," Cassius said. "I brought it down from the old barn this morning. Been there since before the war, I guess."
  I know what it is," Orville said. "I used to have one myself ."
  I'd expected to whip you out of town with it, son-or try to. Now I don't know. I think maybe I'll just walk along beside you with it." He lifted the whip and tried it in air, as if he were testing a fly rod; the old leather creaked, but the whip swished in the dull silent air and startled some of the watchers, of which there were now twenty or twenty-five. Then, without putting the whip down, Cassius took the reins of Orville's mare and tied them up over the saddle horn, turned the mare by catching the bridle, and then whacked her on the rump. "Git up, there!" he said. "Git on home now!" In a softer voice he said to Orville: "You understand, don't you, son? This is kind of hard on an old man like me. I feel old today, and sad. Your mare will just go on home, I reckon."
  I reckon," Orville said.
  Do you have anything more to say?"
  lowly Orville shook his head. "If I do, I can't think of it right now," he said.
  Then I'd like to say I feel pretty bad! I like to see a man come up to himself--but I guess we can say goodby to all that. I guess I can say, too, that I've loved you, boy. I guess you never noticed that. Or maybe you did, and felt a little foolish about it because you didn't understand it. You're young, you've got all your hard life ahead of you. I guess that's it. Look here. This old whip is beginning to crack along the weave. Come along, son." Cassius took Orville's arm and turned him. Together they walked out into the street, toward the crowd that had gathered, as many as forty or fifty men, women, and children by this time, and that broke and scattered before their progress. Side by side they walked north, toward the edge of town, toward the road that led to the Ledyard ranch, leaving me, and in some genuine way leaving the town. I could know further, watching them, that what was leaving, what was being carried away in that tidelike drift toward open country, would not return though I wished it; though others wished it, and with power.
  he sight of the two men together, the big square man in rhe black coat and the slender strong figure of the young cowboy in his uniform of washed-out blue clothes and boots and hat, is one which will stay with me; it is the kind of image that comes back, like a nightmare, with the turning ,w:isons. Love, of that kind, and discovered in that way, on a dusty street in a little town, is a burden that a watcher must afterwards bear; and so I have borne it. I was there. In front of the Courthouse, Cassius dropped the whip and bowed his head a little, and the sad procession continued on its way. One of the boys of the town got the whip as a souvenir. Another got Cassius's gold pocket watch, given away by Cassius as he made his return to his office.
  Keep it as a souvenir, boy," Cassius said, "of the time I whipped a good man out of town--or sell it if you like. Time's nothing to me! I'll have a good deal more of it than I'll ever be able to use, anyway." 
	That is almost the end of the story. There is little more. Orville from that time began to suffer; it could not be otherwise. He had been an authentic hero, an example to boys, and it was, in his heroism, a part of the town's knowledge. His fall could not be a normal fall, from middling virtue to middling shame. The town--and by the town I mean almost all the people in it, as well as that abstract sense of justice which often moves in such places--saw to it that Orville's fall registered on him as an authentic fall, and there can be no doubt that this was instructive for the youth of the town, and a popotent warning. All the usual things were done, all the normal slights were brought out for him. He was unable to walk down the main street of town without laughter from small boys. He was not safe in bar or drugstore, and none of the girls in town were permitted to speak to him. He was challenged to fights, and men sometimes spat when he passed by.
  he town saw to it that Orville felt disgraced, that is the fact of it, and saw to it, in a little while, that Orville departed, after selling his ranch and all his furniture, so that he could meditate elsewhere on life and virtue. And that was cruel, for Orville knew our town and knew no other; but it was not forbidden him to return, and in time he did return.
  eanwhile he went off to law school, in San Francisco, as he had planned for so long. He had the money from the sale of the ranch, and he hoped to make it last him through his six years of study. For four years I did not see him; and then one bright blue winter day in San Francisco, where I had gone to spend a few days of Christmas near an ocean, I met him upstairs in the Ferry Building. He was changed in appearance; he already had the look, that pale and somewhat sullied look, of the dedicated, long-term student; he was thin, and no longer looked strong, but he seemed healthy. I found him standing unhappily in front of that immense relief map of California which in those days was one of the wonders of the city. He was looking across the miniature Sierra Nevada at the little green button which was Albo, where it gleamed on a brown-paper valley.
  uickly he recognized me when I spoke to him. He explained that he was in the first year of law school, and that he often came homesick down to the Ferry Building to look at the papier-mache mountains and the painted lakes and streams. He was embarrassed. He admitted that he was doing well in law school. When he left me, I had a sense of a departing student, of a hungry young man now a little old to be still in college; and it took thought for me to remember the heroic Orville Ledyard of old days.
  nd then twelve years more in Albo passed as in a dream.
Cassius died, and Rose went away, to live in Los Angeles with
an aunt, so it was said. Girls I had known as fresh and happy
faces in Orville's buggy became mothers of children, other
men's children, who, as the years passed, were often tall arrogant boys anxious to enter high school or leave it, and pretty girls obsessed with lipstick, rouge, and clothes. I grew older, and more angry.
  rville returned, finally, sixteen years after he had left. He came back in a car, a Pontiac, with his belongings in the back seat and the trunk. He was still a bachelor. He brought with him from his travels many boxes of books, clothes, and a dog; it was a mild-looking, sad little bloodhound.
  n Albo he took up the practice of law, having already had some seven or eight years of experience in Bakersfield and Modesto, and he did reasonably well from the start; he was a competent lawyer, for Albo, and he made a decent living. After two years he was able to buy the ruins of his family's ranch-the water rights having been sold some years before to the City of Los Angeles by one of the interim owners. He drilled a well, and restored the house, and began to live there again. Two of the old pines remained, though both were pretty well blistered and scaled by heat and drouth;
thc barn and all the fences and corrals had been stolen, board by board, many years before.
  here were few people in the town who even remembered his carly days, and most of those who remembered thought it a kindness to forget. Orville was accepted quickly by the commercial and social leaders in the town, which by this time was an up-to-date tourist center with flashing white motels and restaurants which are mentioned favorably in tourist guidebooks. He was given a sufficient number of chances to decline dinner invitations. He became a distinguished citizen, and when he had a little trouble with a girl from the high school, it was easy for his new friends to make an arrangement which kept the girl quiet; she was happy to accept a cashier's job in a Long Beach restaurant. Two years after his return he was made a member of the Kiwanis Club.
  hus, in middle-class ways, he has come to his fifties. He drinks too much, but he is quiet about it; he never makes a spectacle of himself. In the fall he hunts ducks and geese on the little ponds in the valley and along the aqueduct; and each year he makes a ceremonial deer hunt, with cronies, into the Piute Mountains.
  e is still a reader. By now he has a sprawling erudition of immense scope, on such matters as the histories of Motley and Carlyle, the comic works of Surtees, the novels of Walter Scott. He is one of those isolated, village readers; his erudition is carelessly managed, easily forgotten, full of dark little errors; he has read no Latin for thirty years, but he is accepted as a man of great knowledge, and he owns more than two thousand books. Every three or four years he is asked to make the speech at the high-school graduation.
  e has, I suppose, found ease and comfort by his escape into the type of the country lawyer. It is a place to be, loosefitting and undemanding, and it requires of the men who populate it only that they be content to stay in it; it is a respectable man of middle years, conservative in politics, who hunts a little, who likes to read, and prefers the historians of the last century; a common type. You will find it all over this country, more or less tending to the law in little sun-washed courthouses, entering and idly leaving politics; fishing, or talking of it, in the forests of Maine, listening to dogs bay coon in the piney woods of North Carolina, talking wheat in those villages of the Middle West which are so imperfectly shaded by the grain elevators--everywhere, in fact, where it is possible for men to lose themselves.
  t is not a bad type. There is often a fine haunted look about the eyes, as with Orville, and this can indicate a deep capacity for sympathy. It can also improve a man's looks, and even make him handsome. So Orville is a handsome man, and visitors to the Courthouse are always taken to see him when he is pleading a case; he is a credit to the town, and to the town's climate. His hair is white; he is regarded with indulgent favor by the wives of his friends, and the boys of the town, if they know him at all, respect him in a qualified, half-derisive way because he is a fine wing shot.
  s for me, I do not see him often; we have drifted apart. Possibly we remind each other too strongly of the past, possibly we never had much in common; but we are no longer able to rise to a conversation. We are polite. I think when he reaches sixty we may come around to amusing ourselves with stories of the good old days, but until then I will be content to watch the present. Like Cassius in those last years before he died, I too have more time than I can find a decent se for.

	Table of Contents
	Start