Dale Bailoy teaches in the English Department at the University of Tennessee-Knoxville. His first book, American Nightmares (reviewed in our pages two months ago), grew out of his doctoral dissertation. He says he found this story much more fun to write; we hope you'll agree that reading it is most enjoyable too.
HOW YOU HAVE ENDURED it all these years, I cannot say. Even now that he is dead, I can feel his presence in this house,, this room. It rises in wide waves from the things I've arranged across this table. The diamond ring in its dusty jeweler's box. The black and white photograph of the woman, really just a girl. The close-written letter, yellow now with age.
I could touch these items if I wanted to. If I wanted to, I could lift the letter to my face, smell that musty resonance old paper gets, that gust of antiquity and gloom. And something else, something I must be imagining: a hint of dime-store perfume, the kind a girl might wear. Surely it cannot have survived so long.
But I won't touch these things again. Not until I burn them.
I'll try to be clear if I can.
You need to know that I've lied to you about some things. I am married, though I told you otherwise. And I'm not nearly as obscure as I have led you to believe. I am an artist of sorts -- though I'm not a painter, not the kind of painter I wanted to be anyway, and that's partly why I came here. So if I lied when I told you I was an artist, I told the truth in my way. Also, in some respect I told the truth when I said I wasn't married. Because the truth is, when I said that, I had decided -- or I was in the process of deciding -- that I didn't want to be married. That's the other part of why I came here.
Well, that's all changed now. That's why I'm writing it all down. So I can understand. I'm going to put it all down as clearly as I can remember it.
I need to understand.
This house came to me as such events befall orphans in tales, without hope or expectation, in the hour of my greatest need. I'm sorry if this sounds dramatic.
My parents -- my adoptive parents -- died eight years ago, when an interstate trucker strung out on speed dozed off behind the wheel. In the days after the accident, I had this recurring dream of the truck as they must have seen it in their last conscious moments: three tons of metal careening across the median strip at eighty-seven miles an hour. The dream filled me with intense, paralyzing fear: not of pain, but of the imminence of a disaster I could foresee but not prevent. The dream-wreck occurred with adrenalized leisure. Time ceased to flow at the normal rate. I could perceive everything, but I could act on nothing.
At this time I was twenty-five years old, newly married, just graduated from art school. Already I had learned something of the accommodations our dreams demand. Instead of selling my paintings in trendy Soho galleries as I had vaguely intended, I found employment doing movie posters and covers for cheap paperbacks. The work was enjoyable, often challenging, the money good -- but I knew it wasn't art. In those days, I still told myself I would continue with "real" art, but in my heart I already knew this to be a lie. The death of my parents came as simply another of life's brutish surprises.
It did not make it easier that I had been adopted. I remember thinking that twice in my life I had lost all at once what most people lose piecemeal over the span of a lifetime. I had twice lost my family. Of the first time, the first family, I remember nothing. The second time I cannot forget.
I have tried not to think of these things. Until these recent events, it has been easier than you might think.
It's odd how things start. I'm thinking right now of an old nursery rhyme, the one that goes, "For want of a nail, the shoe was lost; / For want of the shoe, the horse was lost," and so on, all the way up to the loss of the kingdom -- "All for want of a horseshoe nail." I remember I once heard a teacher cite this rhyme as an exercise in false logic. Now I'm not so sure.
I don't know where this begins. Maybe when that trucker smashed across the median strip and crushed my adoptive father's Honda like an empty soda can, or maybe further back, when my mother-- my biological mother -- gave me up for adoption, or maybe {still further back} when my father's cursed seed found purchase in my mother's womb. Or maybe that's just as ridiculous as it sounds. Maybe it begins with my first dawning suspicions of Cynthia back toward the end of the summer, or -even more recently -- with the house, this fairytale inheritance, like something out of a third-rate novel.
Maybe it begins with the phone call.
AT THIS POINT -- the point of the phone call Cynthia and I have been married for seven years, one month, five days, a few hours. A week ago, this figure would not have entered my mind. Now I can think of nothing else.
I do not know the man on the phone, an old man by the sound of him, but he identifies himself as a lawyer. Simon Borden. In the space of a single moment all the oxygen rushes from the room. I grope for breath. I am thinking: Cynthia, oh, Cynthia.
Perhaps I say it aloud, for Borden says, "What? Cynthia?"
When I say nothing -- what can I say? -- he says, "I don't know any Cynthia, Mr. Nicholls. I'm calling in regards to an estate."
"An estate?"
"An inheritance," he says. "A house. Some property, too."
"There must be a mistake," I say. I am at my desk in the upstairs studio where I work: a bright skylit room with windows facing east and west and counters littered by tubes of paint and galleys and sketches. I turn to the window and gaze blindly at the Bay. I see that dream truck I have not seen in years, a leviathan smashing heedless as fate over the median strip.
"My parents died," I say. "There's no one else to leave me anything." Borden shuffles papers. "Those would be your adoptive parents, correct?'
"That's right."
"Have you ever tried to find your real family, Mr. Nicholls?"
"My real family died eight years ago. If you mean my biological family, the answer is no. Why should I?"
"I'm calling on behalf of a biological uncle,' Borden says. "His estate, rather. Lucius Kemp. It seems he hired an investigator to find you. He never contacted you?"
"No."
"Well, it appears he found you at any rate." He hesitates. "Your uncle...passed away a bit over a month ago. His house, his farm -- he left all of it to you. Even his pick-up."
"Where did you say you were calling from?"
"West Virginia."
"And the farm?"
"West Virginia."
So I have an uncle. A week ago this news might have sparked my interest. A week ago it might have moved me.
"Mr. Nicholls?"
"Send the papers to my lawyer," I say.
As I give him the address, the garage door starts up beneath me. Cynthia. I reach over and lock the door. I will tell her I am working.
None of them want me to go -- not my lawyer, not my agent, not my wife.
We can have the house appraised, my lawyer tells me. We can put it on the market. You never need to go there.
You have a deadline, my agent says. You have a contract.
When I tell Cynthia, we are in the kitchen.
"Sell the house," she says from the sink. "What do we need with a house in West Virginia?" She cannot bear to look at me when she says it. She speaks with her face turned down and away, one quarter profile. I can see a delicate curve of cheek, a sliver of upturned nose, a fringe of eyelashes, fuzzed blonde with twilight. I notice she has used the pronoun "we."
On the stove, pots bubble and simmer. A loaf of fresh bread cools on a rack. Spicy smells drift in the air. Cynthia cooks to dispel anxiety. We've been eating well.
"I'm going down there," I say. "I need some time to think."
"You can't just run away from this," Cynthia says.
"You did," I say.
You did, Cynthia.
That's what I'm thinking during the long drive, my headlights probing the swarming dark. Hours on the highway, down and around D.C., 1-66 to 81 South, then west on 64 into desolate and uncharted territory. The broad highway into West Virginia strikes me as anachronistic -- a contemporary blight on these ancient hills. But for the highway and the occasional blaze of small towns hidden in the valleys, the terrain looks as it might have looked two hundred years ago. Unspoiled. Untouched.
Forbidding.
I exit into darkness. Not even a McDonald's or a gas station, just the gray thread of a twisting two-lane road. I am thinking: You did, Cynthia. You ran away.
It's all so banal I can hardly bear to recall it.
Cynthia in tears as I pack my car: a suitcase of warm clothes for autumn in the mountains, a beat-up box of oils and brushes I've hardly used since art school, a sketchbook, an easel, two or three clean, beckoning canvases. I've packed a few groceries, but I leave the thermos of coffee and the paper sack of sandwiches she's made me for the trip.
"Don't you have a deadline?" she says when she sees the canvases.
"Not anymore."
"What about your contract?"
"What about it?"
As I start the car, she leans in the window. "Please, David. Stay. We can work this out."
"I have to go."
"Goddamnit, David, I'm sorry."
I don't know what to say to this.
She says, "You can't run away from this."
And now, as the early morning dark presses down and down, I am thinking, You did, Cynthia. You ran away. My headlights skate across the pavement, across signs and denuded trees that loom over the road like sentinel giants. Here and there, the forest draws back. Sleep-darkened houses crouch in the steep fields.
I am lost.
I stop in the middle of the deserted road and study the map by the dome light. I turn it two or three times to see if a new perspective might help. I study Borden's typewritten directions. I drive on.
Cynthia's face hovers before me, at the limit of my lights. It is her face as I saw it when I confronted her -- glistening with tears, her beauty distorted by sorrow and regret.
"I'm sorry," she said then. She said, "How did you know?"
There must have been a thousand little things, an incremental perception, confirmed at last. Oh, she was careful. How did I know? I might have told her that she began to look through me instead of at me. That when we made love she wasn't there. That she had a glow about her I hadn't seen in years. I might have told her any of these things or all of them, but I didn't. I said nothing, for it didn't matter how I knew. It only mattered that I did.
"I love you," she said.
That's what I'm thinking of when I finally find a landmark I recognize from the directions: a gray wide-slatted barn in a declivity below the road, its tin roof painted with a weathered advertisement for Red Man Chewing Tobacco. Nothing else in sight, not even a house. I might be the first traveler to happen across the barn in a decade or more.
From there it's easy enough. The gas station/general store; two or three miles of scoliotic road, overhung with barren trees; the gate marked NO TRESPASSING. The car jolts over the rutted driveway. In the gray dawn light smudged over the horizon, a mix of evergreens and deciduous trees looms up. And then the trees fall away and the house emerges, a low, rambling stone house with a long front porch and wide, clean windows that throw back the morning light.
I stop the car and get out. A bird calls somewhere.
I start down toward the house, and it feels like coming home.
How did you know? Cynthia had asked me.
How do you ever know?
EVERYTHING IS as I have requested: the key under the mat, the electricity and phone activated. According to my watch, it is six thirty A.M. I call Cynthia.
"I've been worried sick," she says.
"I got lost."
"David, I've been thinking. Maybe I could come --"
"Not yet," I say. "Not now."
I hang up and look around the house. Lucius Kemp. My uncle. There is a certain novelty in having family, in seeing here this visible evidence of his life-- this house, this farm. Like discovering a new continent within yourself, a vast temperate zone you did not know existed, though perhaps at some level you have always known or sensed that it was there, ripe and undiscovered. For a moment, I can almost forget Cynthia in the simple pleasure of discovering this home I did not know I had.
"Who are you, Lucius Kemp?" I say, to hear the sound of my voice here. I shout aloud: "Who are you?"
Nothing. My voice rolls back to me from uninhabited rooms. Like shouting aloud in a graveyard, I think. And then I think: What nonsense. But I do not shout again.
The house is not large: a kitchen with a door into a cellar; a common room with a table, a sofa, a fireplace; two bedrooms and a bathroom off a hall. I fetch my bags from the car, two trips across the gravel drive, into the silent house, down the hall to the larger bedroom. On the second trip, I stop to study the photograph of a woman atop the bureau -- a girl really, her clothes and hair the fashions of another age, her beauty too, a soft rounded voluptuousness women don't possess these days. I think of Cynthia, lean and tall and small-breasted, her body like an athlete's. And then -- because I don't want to think of Cynthia -- I put the photo down, this woman who must have been my aunt.
In the kitchen, I find a can of Maxwell House. I brew a pot and stand out on the porch to watch the morning creep golden down the ridges, across the naked trees. That bird has started up again, away over the hill beyond the barn. The air is chill with a hint of winter coming on. But it feels like home. It feels like home.
I leave my clothes in the suitcase, atop the bed in the spare bedroom. My uncle's clothes are in the closets and in the drawers and I'm not certain what to do with them. For now, I want to leave things as I find them. For a time, I want to be a ghost here. I want to make as little impression as I can on this house, these possessions. Now that I am here, curiosity has seized me. I want to search him out in the things he owns, the way an archaeologist might reconstruct a culture from an arrowhead and a shard of broken pottery. Who is this man? Who are you, Lucius Kemp?
At mid-morning, I set up the easel in the common room. I will work here, in the early light. I place the sketchbook atop the table, lean the canvases against one end of the sofa. But I'm not ready to paint. That will come.
In the meantime, I wander about the house, exhausted from the trip, but wired with caffeine and nervous energy. I think, and for the first time in a week I do not think of Cynthia.
By noon, it has all caught up with me: the trip, the stress of the break with Cynthia, the exhaustion of the drive. In the bedroom, I claw down the sheets. In the moment before sleep seizes me, I have a fleeting thought, an illumination.
Is this the bed he died in?
Once, twice, three times in as many days I speak with Cynthia. Three conversations fraught with strong emotion. I want to come down there, she says. I want to work this out.
But I have my wants, I have my desires.
"What about him?" I ask.
Do you still see him every day at work? Do you find time to sneak away at lunch, to rut like animals in cheap hotels? Do you?
"It's not like that. It never was."
"Then how is it?"
Is it love, then? And isn't that worse?
"Are you still seeing him?"
"Of course not, David," she replies, but by the catch in her throat I know that she is lying.
I stop answering the phone. I listen to it ring and ring, another noise in this house of noises. I can hear them when I sleep and sometimes when I'm wakeful. The shrill wind desolate among the hills. The house settling around me. Voices. I hear voices, faint and faraway, like whispers from another room. I cannot make them out. Sometimes when I try to work I'll find that I have dropped my pencil and pushed my tablet away. I'll wake to myself, hands flat against the table, straining to understand. How long I've been like that I cannot say. The voices hasten into silence. The whole house gathers, listening.
I get up, push my things away, wander restlessly about the house and grounds. In three days, I've explored everything. The house, looking much as it looked the day I arrived, crowded with my uncle's clothes and furniture. The cellar, two dirt-floored rooms separated by a thin partition, each lit by a single bare 100-watt bulb that dangles from the unfinished ceiling. A furnace and an empty oil drum crowd one room; in the other, I find hand-cobbled shelves stocked with mason jars of moonshine. The barn is empty but for a gutted tractor and a rusted Ford F- 150, its keys in the ignition. In the bed of the truck I find tools -- a shovel, a hoe, an old-fashioned hand plow -- and when I start the truck and take it over the first ridge, I discover the little plot he must have used to raise his vegetables. The upturned earth is red with clay -- rocky, hard land for growing even vegetables, much less for farming.
The farm is not a working farm, hasn't been for years. I top off the pick-up from the diesel tank behind the barn and jolt over the rough pastures, feeling at home in the cab of the big truck. The lumpy seat is more comfortable than it looks. The pitted steering wheel feels right against my palms. Whatever Lucius Kemp might have been w other than the drinking man to whom the mason jars of everclear offer mute testimony --he wasn't much of a farmer. Except for the garden, this land hasn't been cultivated in years. Rabbits flee pell-mell across the ridges. Once I scare up a fox. It crouches atop a hillside and glares down at me in my truck. When it stalks away, it slides into the trees like a graceful shadow.
A vision of the man my uncle must have been starts to cohere in my mind. A man grim and spare as these mountains. His house empty of vanity or comfort, of decoration, unfinished but functional. Raw. I think of the woman in the picture, the woman who must have been my aunt. This life must have been a hard life for her. Her beauty, her softness-- they do not square with the house she lived in or with the man who is forming in my mind.
And yet I find that I admire him, somehow. Admire his perseverance in wrenching an existence from such land.
One morning I start to work. In the common room, I prop the picture of my aunt over my sketchbook. I begin to block in her soft features, her eyes, but my interest in the project quickly pales. I move to the porch and try to sketch the lay of my uncle's farm.
Nothing.
Back inside, I sip coffee. I sit in a straight-backed kitchen chair, my hands flat against the table. Listening. That whispering has started up among the empty rooms and I am listening, straining now to make it out. After a while, I find that I have taken up the pencil, that on a fresh sheet I am sketching in the outlines of a face that is lean -- or better, gaunt. A face hungry and unkind.
In the kitchen, the phone rings and rings.
The whisper keeps on, at the very edge of hearing, verging on subliminal. What it says, I cannot know. The phone rings and rings.
Go to hell, Cynthia. I'm working.
At last the phone falls silent. I sketch and sketch, my coffee grown cold.
I am not alone here.
This the first thought that enters my mind when I wake late, well after dawn, after eight o'clock, after nine. My good work habits -- the lifelong discipline of a man who has been self-employed since college --have vanished, evaporated in less than a week alone here. Oh I work, yes. I work when the spirit seizes me, as I eat and sleep and wake now. Today, I wake at 9:36 A.M. I gaze at the hands of the Big Ben alarm clock my uncle left on his night table. The long hand ticks forward a notch. 9:37.
And I am not alone.
The thought presents itself, fully formed, in my mind -- not the product of rational consideration, of logic or even evidence. Simply a feeling. An intuition. I am not alone.
I sit up. Sheets and covers pool in my lap. I shrink within the soft flannel shirt I have stolen from my uncle's drawer, within his worn-out sweats. Listening.
And there it is. A sound from the common room -- not the furtive, fearful rustle of a person trying to be silent, but the simple grace of a person gifted with quiet -- a person who moves quietly not for a reason, but simply because that is the way she moves.
The way you move, though I could not know it then.
I dare not breathe. The silence and the isolation seem to close around me. Four days now without human contact, with just the arbitrary detonations of the phone. Four days in which I have seen no living creature but the birds, the rabbits, the predatory fox.
From the common room, I hear that sound once more, and now I recognize it. Someone is turning the pages of my sketchbook, flipping through it slowly and thoughtfully, with a pause to examine each of the penciled studies. Now I know what has jarred me from sleep: this familiar sound, only half-perceived. I am not alone.
Cynthia, I think. Cynthia, I am sure. Cynthia, I tell myself as I throw back the covers and creep down the narrow hallway, silent myself, oh silent, creeping in my stocking feet. I am thinking: Cynthia. Godamnit, Cynthia.
But it is you.
I did not mean to startle you, and now, remembering, putting it all down -- putting it down so I can make sense of it -- now I know that I did not frighten you, that I could not. Could 1.?
But you turn with a little half-gasp, a hiss of in-drawn breath. You clutch at your breasts as if to show me how I scared you. You say, "Oh! You startled me!" And then, with a guilty glance at the sketchbook: "I mean I knew you were here because I saw your things. But I didn't expect --"
I am across the room without thought. I close the sketchbook firmly, as if to say: You have no business. No right. Is this how we are to communicate, like players in a silent film, with a series of flamboyant, wordless gestures.?
"I made some fresh coffee," you say.
I say, "Who are you?"
Who are you? Who are you with your sad face and your housedress from three decades past, your old-fashioned apron, homemade from a flour sack.? I can see the print heave along the shelf of your bosom (Beeman's Best Self-Rising Flour), the silver chain that dangles there, the handworked locket. I can see your long fingers, your bright nails, see you tremble as you steady yourself against the table. And what I want to know is: Who are you?
You say, "There's fresh coffee."
I can smell it.
Now that my heart has settled, now that I know you pose no danger, I am aware that the room is cold. Perhaps this is a harbinger of winter in these mountains. And so I add a stroke to that portrait of my uncle that has been taking shape inside my head: he was a man who could survive such winters. I think of him snowed in here, in his spartan home. I think of the ranked jars of moonshine on their basement shelf. I shiver with the cold.
"Coffee would be great," I say, and you can feel it palpably, the relief that floods the chill room, our mutual relief that despite the fact that we are strangers, despite the fact that you are standing in my uncle's home in my home -- without an invitation or a word of explanation --despite all, we have decided to be friends.
In the kitchen, I pour coffee into a cream-colored ceramic mug. The earthy smell draws me down into myself, out of the chili incorporeality of the room. The first sip plunges me into the absolute physical essence of my being. For the first time in days or maybe weeks, I seem to inhabit every cell of my body, and I realize suddenly that I have been walking around untethered from myself -- my intellect as unconnected to my flesh as that of some disembodied brain in a third-rate science fiction movie -- since first I became aware of Cynthia and her other man, since, for the first time, I was sure. A warm swell of appreciation rises within me, appreciation for this coffee and the woman who made it. I realize with a start that all this time that I have told myself I would not think of Cynthia, I have been thinking of nothing else. She has been down there in the abyss of my being, unacknowledged but shaping the flow of my thoughts, as influential and unseen as some fathoms-deep ocean current.
Hands cupped around the warm coffee mug, I return to the common room. I half expect you to have disappeared as swiftly and silently as you came, but there you are when I return, prim on the sagging sofa, your legs crossed at the knee. I pull a chair from under the table and sit down across from you.
"I'm sorry for frightening you."
"No, I'm sorry," you say. You nod at the sketchbook. "I didn't have any right, not without asking."
"As far as that goes, I might say you didn't have any right to be here at all."
"I didn't expect anyone to be here."
"You didn't notice the car?" You glance down. I stare at the pink fissure of scalp where your dark
hair parts in the middle and falls straight to your shoulders.
"You knew him, didn't you?"
"I knew him."
"Lucius," I say. Lucius, the mysterious Lucius Kemp. Who else? Who but an...intimate (what other word can I use?) would have a key to the house, would simply let themselves in, uninvited? And now I try to get a fix on your age, but it defies me. You might be twenty-five, you might be thirty-five. Certainly no older. But too young, I think, too young by far for the man I've begun to flesh out in my imagination -- the man who was married to the woman in the photograph, surely no less than thirty years ago and probably more.
"Luke," you say. "That's what I called him."
"You knew each other for a long time." Then it comes to me: your youth, his age, your presence in this room. The key. "You worked for him, didn't you? Cleaned for him, looked after him?"
"I should go," you say. You stand and reach into a pocket beneath your apron. "I'll return the key. I'm sorry to disturb you."
I stand, my hand outstretched. "Please, no, it's okay. I want to know about my uncle, I want to know about...Lucius." I cannot bring myself to call him Luke.
"Maybe you could clean the place for me..." I hesitate, the way you do.
"Emily," you say.
"Emily. And I'm David. I'll pay you, Emily -- whatever he paid you, what do you say? Keep the key, all right?"
"Fine, then," you say, and I see you for what you really are: poor. I think of the darkened houses I saw as I drove in. I think of the weary store and gas station, the only business I saw for twenty miles or more, and I know that you are poor, that everyone in this area is poor, and that you must be glad for the work. I even admire you a little -- the easy way you have of saying, "Fine, then," and preserving thus your pride, as though it doesn't matter, when work, any kind of work, must matter very much.
I reach for the photo I've propped on the table, the woman and her soft-focus old-fashioned beauty, and this is what I say: "This woman -- do you know who she is?"
But it's like I haven't said a word. You turn away, you gaze out the window into the gray fall morning, you don't even answer.
FAMILY. Emily Clark.
Such a simple name, so prosaic, and yet when you are gone, departing as silently and mysteriously as you came, I am left with nothing but mystery. For an hour, two hours, three I have accomplished nothing. I follow as you move about these quarters that need no dusting or sweeping or straightening. This house is almost monastic in its order and simplicity -- without flourish, or vanity, or decoration.
Another stroke added to my mental portrait of this man I did not, could not know. Flesh of my flesh. Blood of my blood. Family. "Who was Lucius Kemp?" I ask you.
You shrug. You say, "He could be a nice man," leaving unspoken the obvious corollary to such a statement: Most times he wasn't.
That's it. Nothing else. You move about with a kind of self-sufficient internal repose, as if there's nothing more to say.
Down the hall and through the second bedroom, across into the master bedroom, back through the common room, into the kitchen, and down the hall again -- like heavenly spheres, predestinate in orbits laid out for them by scientific law, that is how we move, in endless circuit about these silent rooms. There is nothing for you to clean. I see that now.
We stare out of windows, exchange a few words, small hesitant smiles, and I think: You are lying to me. There is nothing for you to clean, there never was, this house is like a barracks: my uncle possessed a sense of order military in its precision. Perhaps I should let you go. There is no work for you to do here. But you knew him, that's what I'm thinking. You knew him.
The money isn't much to me. The company, maybe, is.
Now we are in the bedroom. Do I imagine it, or do you too feel the tension that stands triangulated here between us: me, leaning in the doorway; and you, there by the window, gazing out; the bed between us, rumpled and unmade? Natural tension, so I think, between a lonely man and an attractive woman. Do you feel it? Do you?
"Where do you live?" I say, just to be saying something.
"Not too far from here." You do not turn from the window. You lift your hand and gesture vaguely at the driveway and all that lies beyond it. Toward the whole world.
The phone, then. The ring blasts through the silent house, startling me, but you do not flinch, you do not turn your head.
I wait, hoping it will ring only once or twice, hoping it will stop. Please stop.
The phone rings and rings, shrill, insistent, senseless as the buzzsaw of cicadas on a blistered summer day.
"I'll get it," I say, as though you made some gesture to move for the phone yourself, though of course you haven't.
In the kitchen, I lift the receiver from its cradle, annoyed that I should be interrupted, though what exactly I believe has been interrupted it's hard for me to say. I do not realize that I am more than annoyed until I hear the anger in my voice. "Goddamnit, Cynthia, I thought I asked you not to call for a while. Can you just for a day or two, just that long, can you just please leave me alone?"
I stop, gasping. At the other end, a woman speaks. Not Cynthia, but Susan, my agent. I have a sense of women all about me, entrapping me, enwebbing me in their demands. You stand apart from them, silent in the bedroom, self-contained, gazing expressionlessly into the dark clouds that just this morning have begun to mass atop the ridges. As Susan speaks, a very clear image of you forms in my mind, an image of you standing by the window, face turned to the impassive sky.
Susan says, "David, are you ready to forego this nonsense?"
"No."
"Everyone is trying to reach you. I have been. Cynthia. Your lawyer."
"I'm incommunicado," I say. I like the way it sounds.
"Spare me this crap," she says. "Can you do that? We're all worried sick. Cynthia's half-crazed. She thinks we're going to find you in a tub of tepid water, hacking at your wrists with a butter knife. She's driving everybody nuts. So can you please spare me this crap?" "Fine."
I turn to gaze out the kitchen window at the ramshackle barn, the color of a day-old corpse. Grass slants sere and brown out of the dead earth. Beyond the bright tin of the roof, clouds gather like divisions of gray-faced soldiers. A quick image of Susan's Manhattan office seizes me: cluttered and busy and lined with the art of people more famous and more talented than I am. I could be a million miles from that place. I could be in an entirely different universe.
Susan says: "What the hell is going on, David?"
"I'm retired. I'm going to try to paint."
She makes a noise that is not nice. "I don't know what your deal with Cynthia is and I don't want to know, but this is ridiculous."
"Whatever you say."
"This crap has to stop. I've been putting my ass on the line for you all week now. I don't know how much longer I can stall the people at Bantam. I've given them deaths in the family, I've given them bleeding ulcers, I've even given them the truth. And I don't know what else to give them. They want to see your ideas and frankly, David, they deserve to, because they paid for them. Comprende? They paid for them." "So what?"
"So what? It's called a career, David, and pardon me for being blunt, but if you don't stop fucking around with yours, you're going to find yourself trying to remember when you used to have one."
I lean my head against the refrigerator, and the iced surface is like a cool and soothing hand laid across a feverish brow. I do not say a word. Susan continues in the same vein for a time, and when she is done, I say very calmly and as kindly as I know how:
"I'm not doing the covers. It's that simple. I'm...not...doing...them." I say it very slowly and clearly, without heat, but with long stretches of silence between each syllable, the way you say things to children and foreigners, as if by slowing down, you can make them understand. Then I say, "I'm sorry, I really am. But I'm not doing them. Tell them whatever you have to tell them. Tell them I'll return the money and I will. But I'm not doing them. Okay?"
"What's going on, David.?" she asks. "What are you doing.?"
"Art," I say, and maybe that's what I really intend. I don't know myself, and I certainly don't know what to say to her. "Real art."
And she says, with a note of genuine compassion in her voice, "For Christ's sake, David, you're not an artist. You're an illustrator. A damned good one, but only an illustrator. Haven't you realized that yet.?" Then, very gently and before I can reply, as if I would know how to, she hangs up on me.
I stand there, the phone cradled between my ear and shoulder and my forehead propped against the chill surface of the refrigerator, until I trigger an automated recording somewhere in the belly of the phone system. "If you would like to make a call --"
I drop the receiver so that it swings in long parabolas at the end of its cord and walk into the common room.
"Emily," I say. And louder, "Emily!"
Nothing. Nothing but that unique and watchful stillness that comes over an empty house. Just nothing. Knowing that it's useless, but unable to help myself, I walk through the house and then I walk through it again. And you are nowhere to be found. You are nowhere.
I did not hear you leave, I did not hear a car start. I see you in my mind, then, I see you walking down the long drive on foot, walking home, too poor even to own or drive a car, and something of the magnitude of your poverty is visited upon me. For a moment, I finger my keys. I study the slim, shiny key to my Acura and the dull, blunt key to my uncle's pickup, which really, now that I consider it, I suddenly prefer to drive. And then I think about poverty and the pride I sensed within you, and I know that if I should start down the long drive and find you and offer you a ride, you very likely will be too humiliated ever to return.
I want you to come back. I hardly know you, but I want you to come back.
Soon.
I sit down at the table and gaze at the photo of the woman who must have been my aunt, but all I can think about is Emily Clark, all I can think about is you. You and the questions you never answered. You and the questions I did not ask, some simple and some too complex for words. Like: Who is Lucius Kemp? Like: Is it possible to fall in love with a woman you do not even know?
Until this moment, I have not believed in love, not love as in a book or movie. Not love that can launch a thousand ships.
But one thing I do not consider, though now it occurs to me that perhaps I should have: why, spiking through this lucid passion that has possessed me, is my rage and anger at Cynthia -- Cynthia and her little man -- like a razor wire heated to a white-hot incandescence? Why?
This I do not consider.
After a while, it occurs to me that I should work. That I should begin the task of proving, to myself at least, that I am more than an illustrator.
But first, I stalk once more through this house. I make my way from room to room in irritable compass, like a prisoner in his cell, or a lion in his cage.
And that is when I notice: You have gone, your work clone for the day, but you have left my bed unmade.
The next morning I wake up and dress in my uncle's clothes. There is no washing machine, everything I brought is dirty, and as I root through his drawers for something to wear I cannot help but wonder: Did you wash his clothes for him? Then this prosaic question is eclipsed by awe: in the back corner of a bottom drawer, stuffed under a paint-stained sweater, I find a dusty velvet box, and in the box, I find a ring. A diamond ring.
My fingers tremble as I lift it to the window. Clouds have continued to gather overnight -- like a metal plate clamped atop the ridges, impermeable as the lid of a pressure cooker -- but what light there is, the diamond shatters into a thousand shards, so that for a moment, as I shift the ring, searching out its flaws, the dim room is transformed by slow-turning luminescence.
As for flaws, there are none.
Possibilities unfold from this seed. Whose ring was this? The woman in the photo? Another woman yet unknown to me? What prosaic tragedies shaped my uncle's existence? I think, fingering the ring. Or, I think, maybe it is yours.
These possibilities whirl in my thoughts as I place the ring by the photo in the common room. Another question for you. Another mystery only you can solve.
Then I settle in to work. The house is whispering to me again, a voice faint and faraway, undecipherable, but compelling. Whispering, whispering, whispering. I am not alone here, and yet I do not fear. All day in the common room, I labor over the painting. Listen and labor,, hesitantly reaching out to daub a little gray onto the clean canvas, a little brown, a little black. That face. That lean and hungry face.
Later, when the copper coin of the sun, without heat or light, has fallen from the sky and only darkness wells beyond the windows, the phone begins to ring. I put aside my brushes and listen as it rings.
Cynthia, I think. Oh, Cynthia, Cynthia.
But I do not answer.
Silence then. In the stillness, I take up a pencil and start to doodle in my sketchbook. The long curve of a cheek that will not come. The shine of your eyes. And this is what I learn: I do not know what you look like.
I cannot remember what you look like.
It disturbs me. Maybe you'll come, I think. Maybe you'll come.
I resolve to wait.
You do not come.
When I wake, you are there. In the common room I find you, the velvet ring box open on the table before you, the picture of my aunt now turned away.
"Emily?" I say. "Emily?"
Without turning, you gesture at the painting on its easel. "That's him," you say. "That's Lucius Kemp. You know him after all."
Him. That lean face, those hungry eyes. Good God, I think. Good God. I am thinking of the woman in the photo, her soft curves, her gentle beauty. I am thinking: he must have eaten her alive. He must have devoured her.
"Who is the woman?" I say. "Who is the woman in the photo?"
But you do not answer.
The look in your eyes when you turn to me is like no look I've ever seen before. You do not speak. I am not prepared for what follows: you stand and your fury drives me back, down the hall and into the bedroom and the rumpled bed, the sheets like soft arms reaching.
I am not prepared for your chill beauty as wordless we come together, like animals in rut--.
--like Cynthia, some deranged part of my mind babbles, like Cynthia--.
--and this thought just makes it stronger, stranger, sweeter.
"Emily," I say. "Emily, Emily, Emily."
You do not speak. Your body is beautiful but icy, icy cold -- cold from the long walk you've made to get here, so cold that I cannot chafe the blood into your flesh. From now on I will drive you, I think. From now on I will drive you.
And then there is no thinking. Just the vision of your beauty moving over me, that locket swinging there between your ivory breasts.
Afterward, we talk -- or I talk. Whatever secrets you possess you hold fast within yourself. But I, I share my lies: I am a painter, I am not married. Lies, all lies. I'm sorry for the lies.
Then sleep, and when I wake, I find that you are gone.
Gone.
All day, and then another day, waiting, and still you do not come.
A few flakes of snow drift from the gun-metal sky, but the storm holds off, burgeoning. Outside, the wind is cutting and chill, but the clouds do not move; grim and implacable they lour above this barren farm, this bowl among the steep and ugly hills, this inheritance.
No work today. I cannot bear to look at the unfinished painting. I cannot bear to touch it. One thing I know, however: It is magnificent. Like nothing I have ever done or will ever do again.
It lives.
At noon, the phone starts its incessant buzzing. I reach to unplug it, but then desist. I like the sound of it -- of her, Cynthia -- echoing helpless among these empty rooms. Let her worry about me for a change. Let her wonder about me.
Then, at last, it stops.
I wait.
The phone does not ring again.
Eight o'clock. Nine o'clock. And still you do not come.
Down the wooden steps, in the cellar, I pluck a jar of moonshine from the shelf, spin loose the rusty lid. The sharp odor of cheap alcohol washes out at me as I tip the jar to my lips. It tastes awful, like a rat had drowned in the still that brewed it. Bitter, awful, burning stuff -- but balm to soothe me nonetheless. Oh, yes. So I tilt the jar to my lips again, I take another sip, and that is when I see it, shoved back in the spidery darkness at the rear of the shelf. Not shoved there and forgotten. Hidden. Hidden, though how I know this I cannot say. Hidden, I think.
And then I realize that I'm not thinking it at all. I'm hearing it. Hearing it whispered from the shadows at the corners of the room, from the low and looming ceiling where the naked light bulb swings, from the very walls, breathing out from them. Hidden.
Icy fingers stir the hairs at the back of my neck.
Who is the whisperer in the house?
I tilt the mason jar to my lips once more. "For courage," I say, and I
say it aloud. I won't be silenced. I won't be fearful. Not here. Not in my own house.
I'm damned if I will.
I swish the moonshine around in my mouth, my taste buds stunned insensible by the foulness of the stuff. Then I lift my hand, extend it into the cobwebs at the back of the shelf, and pluck it forth:
An envelope, gone yellow now with age. It must have been white once, lacy. Scalloped edges, a mucus-stain of glue around its unsealed flap. My fingers slide along the paper, slick and cheap, pretty in a girlish way
-- the kind of stationery that might appeal to a country girl hungry for beauty, purchased in a dime store, hoarded like a miser's gold. I lift it to my nostrils, inhale that scent which should not, could not have survived, that ghost of a scent, that cheap perfume, this too the kind of thing a girl might buy.
Another swig of moonshine, and then I put the open jar on the shelf. There in the dank cellar, I lift the torn flap and slip out a page of the same slick paper, once crumpled as if in anger, now smoothed flat. My fingers shake as I unfold it. Words sprawl across the page in a close untutored hand:
It aint right what we did. Its sinful. I can't stand the way folks look at me, I know how they whisper. I heard when Mr. Wright told you he couldn't have a girl like me in school no more. You shaking your head saying you don't know how to handle me, saying I won't tell you who the daddy is. I hate you Lucius Kemp, I won't ever ever forgive you what you done to me and if Daddy was alive he'd hate you to. I'm glad Em took the baby, I did it just to spite you. You'll never be able to do it the way you done me. She'll find someone to see its taken care of. When you find this I'll be gone and I'm not ever coming back but I told her what you done. You see if she ever marries you now, you see if she
The letter breaks off, unfinished. But he found it, didn't he, and finding, read it? The whole house is whispering now, and this is what it tells me: he found it and he read it and he crushed it between his callused palms. In his rage. His fury. I can feel his fury in this room.
The date at the top reads November 4, 1961. Not more than a week after my birthday.
I can see them in my mind, his gaunt and hungry face, and her face too, the face in the photograph, that softly vulnerable beauty. More like a girl's than like a woman's. Mother. Father. Oh mother, I am thinking.
Dear god, how I hope that you escaped him.
How long I stand there, I do not know.
Finally I come to myself, her letter, my mother's letter, crushed in my hand, and when I do, I reach out and grasp the jar of moonshine and tilt it to my lips. Up the stairs then, into the night house. The fire has died to embers. That chill is in the room. When I shut off the light and step to the window I see that the snow has started at last. It comes down in swift, tiny flakes, like grains of salt or rice. I can hear them ticking against the window. I can see them piling up out there, burying the farm.
I find the phone numbers in my wallet: home and office. Let me know if you need anything, he had said. Feel free to call. It's after eleven, too late to ring him up, but I do it anyway, punching out the number in the dull copper wash of light over the kitchen sink. I have to know.
The phone rings and rings. He's old. I give him time.
"Hello?" His old man's voice.
"Mr. Borden?"
"Hello? Who's this?
"Mr. Borden, it's me. David Nicholls, you remember? Lucius Kemp's..." How can I bring myself to say it? "Lucius Kemp's nephew."
"Sure," he says. "I remember. Kind of late, don't you think?"
"I'm sorry about that. I need to talk."
"I see," he says.
Silence then, waiting. I reach out and switch off the light, liking the dark, and the way the snow blurs past the window, and how the wind sounds mournful in the hollows.
"I haven't slept too good in years," he says. "I reckon I got time to talk. You doing all right up there?"
"Fine." I tip the mason jar to my throat. Like drinking rubbing alcohol, like drinking gas. "Fine."
"You don't sound too good."
"Just watching the snow."
He snorts. "I hope you're well-provisioned, son. This front's supposed to dump a foot or more. Three, four days maybe, 'fore the plows make it up that way."
"I'll be okay." Another taste of moonshine. I can feel it coursing through my veins. I close my eyes. I say, "Mr. Borden, how well did you know my...my uncle?"
"Gosh, I don't know. Since I was a boy, I guess. I did all his legal work for thirty years or more. He never told me he was looking for you, though."
"Why do you think he was?"
"Don't know. He never talked about that. Never mentioned you nor Katie Ellen much. He didn't have any family, though. Maybe he just got to feeling lonely." He pauses, and when he says, "That happens to old folks, I guess," I get the sense he's speaking from experience. "Katie Ellen?"
"Your mother," he says. "Luke's sister, you know."
"Do you know who my father was?" I ask. But I know myself.
Oh, I know. I know the worst of it. I open my eyes, intending now to face it, and beyond the window the snow is blurring faster than it has blurred before, and when I touch my face, what I feel is tears.
Borden sighs. "Naw. People didn't talk about such things in those days. A pregnant woman who wasn't married -- well, you just didn't talk about it outside of blood. I don't know for sure if your uncle ever knew who your daddy was, but I expect he didn't. If he had a known, I think he probably would a killed him."
It's all I can do not to laugh aloud at the irony of this: Lucius Kemp not knowing who my father was. As if he didn't own a mirror. "What happened to Katie Ellen?" I say.
"She gave you up for adoption, of course. There wasn't anything else she could do back then, not in these parts, anyway. After that she stuck around for just a week or two, and then she up and left. People talk, you know, and she got plumb tired of listening. That was a hard year for your mother, a hard year for your uncle, too. He never talked about it, but you could tell it hurt him."
"He never married?"
"Naw. Almost, once, but...He never married. Lived alone up there, worked just hard enough to make ends meet. Just drank his home-brewed whiskey and brooded. Your uncle was not a happy man." "How did he die?"
"I think you know," he says.
"Tell me anyway."
"Hung himself. Out in the barn. He hung there three weeks before a fellow found him. Fellow had gone up to see about a broke-down tractor Luke had talked about selling." "Why didn't you tell me?"
"Well, hell, son, I didn't see any need for you to know."
Another silence then, a long, uneasy one, as if he knows he should have told me this, and perhaps he does.
At last he says, "I need to get some sleep. Old bones, you know. Why don't you call me in a day or two? We'll talk."
"Wait a minute. There's one more thing."
"What's that?"
"Emily Clark," I say. "You ever hear of a woman named Emily Clark?"
"Where'd you hear that name, son?"
"Who is she?"
"That was the woman your uncle was set to marry. She left about the same time as your mother. Nobody ever heard anything from her either. Like I said, it was a hard year for your uncle. I don't believe he ever got over it."
I do not know what sound it is that I have made, but I can feel it in my throat. Caught there. Like some small and fearful creature.
"Mr. Nicholls.? Are you okay?"
I do not say a word.
Just then a white glare floods the kitchen. Outside the window, each snowflake catches fire, like a storm of swarming meteors. I cannot speak for the choking horror that rises up inside me. I wheel around, clutching the phone in one white-knuckled hand, and stare out through the doorway into the common room. Outside the windows there burn the lights of an approaching car. I can hear the sound of its tires spinning in the snow, its engine racing.
"Mr. Nicholls," Simon Borden says. "Just what the hell have you gotten yourself into up there?"
I do not answer. With nerveless fingers, I rack the phone. By the time I reach the porch, the driver has cut the engine. The headlights still burn, like searchlights through the storm. I can see nothing, no one, only the lights. A car door opens. My heart seizes up inside me. The bitter stench of scorched rubber hangs like hatred in the air.
I cannot stop myself. I'm calling out your name like a man who's lost or drowning, seeking solace as the black waters close above my head.
"Emily!" I am calling. "Emily! Emily! Emily!"
It's not you. Of course it couldn't be. The syllables of your name die in my throat as I watch a figure emerge from the car, moving uncertainly across the broken, icy ground. The storm spits and swirls. The figure stops before the car, backlit by the headlights, its shadow grasping through the swirling fog of snow.
The figure says, "David? Is that you?"
Christ. Cynthia.
"What are you doing here?" I say. "I told you not to come."
"Is that you?"
"Of course it is. Who else would it be?"
"It doesn't look like you," she says.
And perhaps it doesn't: Here I stand in another man's warm flannel, on the porch of another man's house, looking at a woman who should have been the wife of another man. The one she left me for.
She bends to adjust her shoe. "Damn storm," she says. "I didn't think
I was going to make it. It's freezing out here."
Cynthia says, "Aren't you going to invite me in?"
"Come in, Cynthia."
I turn without looking back. Inside, I throw a log on the fire, jab at it with the poker. Sparks swirl up the flue. A few tongues of flame lick out of the coals. The headlights go out abruptly, the car door shuts with a thunk. I am waiting for her. Waiting here, a jar of moonshine in my hand, the smell of the fire tickling in my nostrils.
She enters with a gust of snow, the door swinging away from her to bang against the wall. Her bag hits the floor with a thunk. She shucks her long black coat, and she's wearing heels, loose silk pants that flare at the ankles, a peasant blouse. All black and accented with lots of silver jewelry: a silver herringbone chain, a silver pin in the shape of a Halloween cat over her left breast, lots of silvery bangles that tinkle musically on her thin wrists. When she turns to slam the door, I see she's angry. I can see it in the rigid line of her shoulders and her dark hair flying loose about her face. I can see it in her thin cheeks, flushed with more than cold.
"Jesus Christ, David," she says. "You could at least give me a hand."
"Shut up," I say. "You shut the hell up. Nobody asked you to come here."
She recoils, a new expression rising into her face.
I have never spoken to her this way before -- her or any woman. I can feel the rage coiling in my guts like uneasy serpents. I take a drink of the moonshine and place the jar atop the table. I fetch a jelly glass from the kitchen and dump three fingers of everclear into the bottom. She is gazing at the portrait when I return.
"Well, I have to stay now," she says. "Until the storm breaks anyway."
"You shouldn't have come."
"I was worried about you. You could have answered the phone!'
"I told you not to call."
She turns away, circling warily. I'm watching her, the long lines of her body beneath her clothes, her eyes as they rove and index, checking off the contents of the room: the furniture, cheap but serviceable, the cramped quarters, and the rough-hewn floor below the easel, spattered now with careless drops of paint. She pauses for a moment when she sees the letter and the photograph, and her eyes widen when she sees the ring, but she decides not to mention it. I can see the decision forming in the narrow FOLDS OF HER EYES AND THE SET OF HER LIPS, AND i KNOW THAT i WILL HEAR ABOUT it later.
"I'm sorry," she says finally. "Sorry for coming, I didn't know what else to do. I can't sleep or eat, I can't work or even think. I've been worried sick." She lifts the jelly glass of moonshine from the table, sniffs it warily, and puts it down. "What is this stuff?'
"Don't drink it if you don't want it."
"Can you just quit it, please?"
"Are you still fucking him?"
"David, quit it, okay?"
We sit there for a time, listening to the storm outside. The fire spits and crackles. I sip at my mason jar, feeling the moonshine zipping through my blood.
"Cold in here," Cynthia says.
I can feel it, too: a cold deeper than mere cold, a numbness that creeps beneath the skin and ices up the bones. A cold like no cold I have ever felt until I came here, no natural cold. If the furnace worked, if the whole damned house was burning, that cold would linger.
But all I say is: "I didn't think to order oil." And this, too, is true.
Cynthia shivers.
"Drink the moonshine," I say, "it'll warm you up a little."
She picks up the glass and sips at it, her nose wrinkling. After a while, she starts to speak. "I just want you to know I love you," she says, and I am thinking:
Oh, Emily, Emily.
I am thinking of you.
She says, "I had to come, I had to let you know. I ended it, David. I told him I wouldn't see him anymore, I told him that I love you and that I had made a mistake. I told him the truth. I told him that I love you, that I was going to see if it wasn't too late to save the bond we used to have. I want to save it, if we can. I want you to come home. It doesn't feel right at home without you."
She says this without looking at me. She says it with her eyes averted, with her face averted; she expels the words in brief staccato bursts between her in-drawn breaths, like an actress reeling lines she's memorized but doesn't have much feeling for. It has the ring of falsity, of a speech constructed and memorized during a long drive, which she has undertaken for reasons she does not even know herself. Just lies, more lies.
And I am thinking: Emily, Emily.
Finished, Cynthia meets my gaze at last, an expectant look on her face. I see her through a haze -- as through an ice-rimed window or a ruststained mirror.
"As soon as the roads are clear," I say, "I want you to leave."
I take another long drink of moonshine, the wide-mouthed jar nearly empty now. I can feel it burning into me, fueling my resentment and my rage.
Cynthia stares at me, her mouth open, as I lever myself out of my chair. The room wheels around me vertiginously as I move past her to the hall. For a moment, I am afraid I will be sick, and then the feeling passes. Cynthia catches me at the door to the master bedroom, and there I turn to her, waving her away vaguely, breathing out my fumes at her, saying hatefully and without remorse:
"You leave me alone. You go to hell."
I wrench loose from her and move to the bed.
She's saying, "David, please --"
But she's saying it from very far away. I see her up there, far away, see her mouth moving, but I can't hear the words she's saying, and then the soiled bed--.
-- Emily --.
-- reaches up to catch me, and I can't see a thing.
IN THE NIGHT she comes to me, as I suppose I knew she would. Her way, her weakness, her passage out of loneliness.
Cynthia, oh Cynthia, inconstant as the moon. I forgive you, I forgive you now.
When she comes the room beats with a strange and molten light, the light of storm and radiant snow, raining out of night and blackness and beating back the dark with its unearthly glow. What wakes me I do not know, but there she is, without a stitch of clothing, moving toward me so soundlessly the hinges of her body might be oiled, the light agleam and playful along the smooth facets of her body and her flesh, like silken steel beneath my reaching fingers.
Thick-headed with booze, stunned by sleep, I rise up to meet her. Now, after all that I have said, all the unforgivable words, I embrace her. I take what solace she can offer. Warm. So warm.
And sometime in the middle of her wordless cries, I too am speaking whispering aloud in a voice tremulous with love and need, like a prayer or invocation: "Emily, Emily."
I can sense you in the room.
Through my slitted eyes, I can see you in the doorway looking on.
I can feel you, your presence: beyond the light or the cold or the warm imperative of Cynthia beneath me. "Emily," I say. "Emily."
Now Cynthia is speaking, saying, "What? Who?" I can feel the anger in her voice, the self-righteous anger she has no right to.
Like the dank waters of a poisoned well, the rage boils out of me.
"Who?" Cynthia hisses. "What did you say? Who?"
She claws at me, scrabbling at the sheets, trying to get away.
Another glance then, at you, you, Emily, waiting, watchful from the door, and I am on her. My fingers too can claw. My fingers grasp and squeeze.
For you. For you.
I clutch her in her throes, I clasp her to me. I will have her. I will have what he has had and more.
Afterward, darkness closes around me, swift and certain. Dreams haunt me: this house of whispers, a lonely stretch of interstate, an on-looming truck. When I wake, the storm has passed. The light in the room is the bright warm light of morning sun, a thousand times reflected by a blanket of new-fallen snow. And now I remember, I remember it all: how Cynthia came to me in the night, what happened afterward. I am sure that it is just another dream. But when I roll over, when I reach out my hand, my fingers fall on flesh that's cold and dead.
Flesh like your flesh, Emily.
This is what I do:
In the barn, I fetch my father's shovel from the bed of the pick-up. I cannot dig a grave through snow and half-frozen ground, and if I could, I dare not risk it: the long, hungry months have commenced, and surely some predatory beast would dig her up, and devour her. Perhaps the fox. Back then, across the bright frozen wasteland of the yard, back to the house, where I wrap Cynthia in sheets. She has begun to stiffen. Her flesh is blue and cold, her arms and legs refuse to unfold, and when I lug her into the cellar, I am half-amazed at how weighty and inert her slim body has become.
I am fighting back the tears, though whether they are tears of grief or fear I cannot say. I am thinking of you, Emily.
I am thinking of you as the shovel bites into the dusty floor; thinking of you with each spadeful of dry, remorseless earth; thinking of you when I clamber from the grave to open a jar of moonshine and slake my weary thirst.
Emily. Emily Clark.
The house seems to whisper your name. I can hear it in the creaking joists and in the roof, complaining under its load of autumn snow. Down here it is cold, cold. Even the moonshine doesn't warm me, even the work, the hard, hard work of digging Cynthia's grave.
How long I labor there, I cannot say. I lose myself in the work, all practical considerations flee before its grim imperative. When the blade of the shovel clangs against something hard, I am drawn back to myself, to the cellar, to the grave, which I have made large and wide and deep. A single bone protrudes from the earth.
Other bones then, many of them, too many. I cannot identify them, but I know they are human. The skulls confirm it: two of them, narrow and yellow with ensconcing earth, staring blind and mute at the raftered ceiling.
And something else.
I drop the shovel and pluck it from its bed of earth. A gleaming silver trinket, a hand-worked locket. I know where I saw it last: swinging in the hollow between your ivory breasts.
With my work-grimed fingers I pry it open to stare, hip deep in the earth of your grave, at the photos within. Two photos: the first, a grim black and white studio shot of the man in the portrait upstairs, my father, Lucius Kemp; the second also a studio shot, of a woman I can only vaguely recognize, but whom I know.
You, Emily. You.
How you have endured it all these years -- trapped here in the house of the man who murdered you -- how you have stood it:, I cannot say. Spirits linger. Might not they too be driven to madness and revenge?
How it happened, I cannot say with any certainty. I have my suspicions, my intimations.
Who are you, Lucius Kemp?
I think I know. I fear I am my father's son.
After he raped my mother, his sister, after I was born and spirited away, he came upon her, didn't he? Found the letter even as she wrote it, and in his rage he murdered her. And you, Emily, you must have had your suspicions then, after everything my mother told you. So you came to him, perhaps you came upon him, even, as he buried her in her cellar grave. And so he killed you too. Perhaps he did it when you came to return his diamond to him.
Long years you waited for your revenge. Did you drive him to his hangman's noose?
I can't know for sure. I cannot say.
But you took me in my weakness, didn't you? Out of my despair and need you shaped yourself, you clothed yourself in the flesh of my desire. The sin of the father, visited upon the son. That's how it must have been.
To think I loved you. To think I love you still.
The snow is melting. The mercury in the thermometer on my father's porch has begun to creep upward. The storm is past.
The phone rings and rings -- though who it is I can only guess. Susan, maybe. Simon Borden perhaps. It doesn't matter. Soon someone will come looking. Maybe they'll read this, though it is not for them that I have written it. I wrote it for myself, Emily. I wrote it for you.
But you are gone. Your spirit has fled this house, those bones. I feel nothing of you. Not your mystery, or your icy presence, the chill of long years in the grave, hungry for the strength of living flesh to incarnate your rage. Nothing. Even the whispers have fallen silent. What is left?
Just me. Just the house my father built and furnished in his comfortless fashion. Just this photo, this ring, this letter -- relics of a story I did not want to know and do not want to remember. The presence of my father breathes out from these meager possessions, breathes out at me from the very walls of this house. In getting to know Lucius Kemp -- in that, at least, I succeeded. And in getting to know myself. But at what price?
For two guilt-haunted days I have awaited your return. In vain, of course, I understand that now. You've passed on wherever spirits pass to, your purpose here accomplished.
What else remains for me to do?
I will burn these things. The photograph. The letter. The ring too, though fire will only blacken it.
And then I will walk down into the cellar, to the grave in the cellar. I dug it wide, I dug it deep. My mother awaits me there. My wife. There, atop my bed of bones, pressed close against Cynthia's icy flesh, I will open my mouth and slide in the cold barrel of the revolver I found in my father's closet. I will pull the trigger, Emily, end this passage of my life and start anew.
I am coming, Emily. I am coming.
~~~~~~~~
By Dale Bailey